> You contradict yourself when stating innovation is improving current executions of ideas. Too much of this, and suddenly it's something called theft?
No, you got it all wrong. I argue that too little improvement of current executions is theft. I can't clone Facebook completely, change the logo, add a dislike button and then call it my own. That's theft, not innovation. However, I could take all the best ideas from Facebook, from Twitter, Gowalla etc. and create a unique social network I could call my own.
> If you merely copy the execution of the competition 1:1, you won't win over your competitor. You need to offer a key advantage. That's where the innovation takes place: the small step differentiating your execution from the original. In doing so, you don't steal, but add something. Adding something can never be stealing.
Well, you actually don't necessarily need a better and improved product. The only thing you need to succeed as a clone is better marketing.
I think we actually agree that innovation is just improvement on the current execution.
If I grab your book while you're not looking, and xerox a few pages, I've copied some copyright material. Once I put the book back, YOU CAN'T TELL I'VE DONE IT. That's unlike actually removing the book from your posession. You can tell I've done that.
If you can't tell I've done it, it isn't theft. It's something else. All the laws in the world don't make it otherwise.
Copying a book for yourself is one thing, releasing a copy with another name and some minor additions and calling it your own is another thing.
You contradict yourself when stating innovation is improving current executions of ideas. Too much of this, and suddenly it's something called theft?
If you merely copy the execution of the competition 1:1, you won't win over your competitor. You need to offer a key advantage. That's where the innovation takes place: the small step differentiating your execution from the original. In doing so, you don't steal, but add something. Adding something can never be stealing.