We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26683670.
Seriously what is wrong with you? I get that cryto-anarchist are hip and think they're so cool, but there is a real human cost here. Are you OK with that?
Right. Because those images were just created magically? Someone took them. And there's a market for them.
If there's no market for such pictures, likely less children will suffer the consequences.
Fighting the crime directly is important, but so is doing it indirectly.
Read about the suicide rates in the UK by women before and after the country changed the type of gas stoves. Indirect effects can be very strong.
Reconsider your morals and logic.
The attempt to fight indirectly clearly had not succeeded so far. And most often is used as a pretext for introducing mechanisms that afterwards are used for censorship.
I don't advocate for one policy or another. In fact i'd be happy if i was wrong and the fight with numbers was actually useful, but logic tells that it isn't.
No it doesn't.
If you'd like to offer advice about HN moderation, breaking the site guidelines while doing so is unlikely to persuade.
The market will always exist: pedophiles. They have been and will be among us until the end of times.
> Fighting the crime directly is important, but so is doing it indirectly.
Yes, but the difference is so abysmal that you know where is more important to put the effort. Stopping even 1 child of being abused is better than stopping the sharing of 1 million child porn pics.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2013_International_child_porno...
have you talked to those children and asked whether or not they think publically displaying and selling images of their abuse is abuse?
I don't advocate for one policy or another. In fact i'd be happy if i was wrong and the fight with numbers was actually useful. But i am rather sceptical about it, because the only argument its supporters have is "think of the children, you monster!"
The grandparent post said (abbreviating):
But hosting isn't a morality question, they are just storing a number, and hosting company should not have to care what interpretations of a number can exist.
The parent post responded, saying that this is a flawed line of reasoning, because it (imo purposefully) glosses over an important distinction between hosting child porn and hosting most numbers: but there is a real human cost here
hope this helps you come to a decision on whether hosting child porn is bad or not!If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and sticking to the rules when posting here, we'd be grateful.
"Playing opera on my stereo isn't a morality question, I'm just creating vibrations in the air, and I should not have to care what interpretations of those vibrations can exist when I play it at 4am with the dial cranked to 11"
can you see how playing semantic games to try to dodge responsibility for poor behavior can be irritating even in the best of circumstances?
they are just storing atoms. the storage company should not have to care about what configurations the atoms can exist in.
He also learned his lesson over a decade ago, and furthering that lesson unnecessarily as you have here borders on harassment.