After paying the $5800 requested, would it then be legal to scan and distribute the lot online for free? If not, then the "bear the costs of that request" claim would not be legitimate. I don't know the answer, but I think this is central to the issue.
According to the original article no, and that I completely agree is a problem.
> If not, then the "bear the costs of that request" claim would not be legitimate.
Of course it would, this and that are unrelated issues.
Or put the document on the website where it belongs, and eat the cost of storage and data transfer just like you do with all your other state-run websites.
There’s no mention of scanning here, only copying.
Furthermore even if they did scan it and kept the digital data around, if they only did it because of the request and would not otherwise that’s still a cost of fulfilling the request.
> The state needs a digital copy no matter what.
That obviously is not the case since they do not have one.
TBF that one requesting information would bear the costs of that request does make sense, for instance FOIA requesters may get charged the costs of searching, collecting, and copying the records they're asking for. One could debate the price of 20c a page, but if they are bound books to be copied page by page, the price is if anything low: at 10s a page it's 2 weeks, full time, for an employee.
If it's a bunch of binder and there's a copy machine which can be fed piles of loose pages then it's bullshit. Such an administration would have access to relatively large-scale copier, the CPP of which can't be above 10c, and likely is below 5c.