Re:Scram Switch
by CobaltFire on Wednesday March 31, 2021 @08:13PM
(#26655045)
For nuclear power your third paragraph isn’t anywhere in the same universe.
SCRAM drills are held regularly, but under no circumstances is any intentional level of risk in critical safety systems accepted on the plants I worked on.
Re:Scram Switch
by throwawayboise on Wednesday March 31, 2021 @08:16PM
(#26655068)
I was present in a data center during a scheduled complete shut-down so that some significant power and equipment moves could be done. At the designated time, the manager ceremoniously pressed the Big Red Button by the door and.... nothing happened.
So an electrician was sent to throw some switches elsewhere in the building.
I never got a clear explanation of what went wrong, only that it had been "fixed" and would work if needed in the future.
In a computer system, you ought to be able to test systems to make sure they behave correctly under the consequences of a switch press. You could also test them—there may be times when it is ok to press the switch, or where you have redundancy such that two switches must be pressed but you only press one to test.
But I think another alternative is to not have the mechanism used extremely rarely. I think it can be good to accept cases where things go wrong a bit from time to time so that people have practice dealing with them as the alternative is to only have things go wrong under some enormous catastrophe when no one will have any idea what to do.