Steering a small startup is one thing. Steering a 10k person public company is entirely different.
I doubt Steve Jobs at age 26 could have saved Apple from impending doom in 1996. Even at age 41, with all his additional skill/experience, it was far from easy for him.
That said, from PG's point of view as an investor, the important thing is to get to an exit, and hope that for the sake of the company, part of what makes the founders 'good' is the ability to recognize when it's time to step aside.
Fair questions: would Apple be facing impending doom in 1996 if Jobs hadn't been ousted and instead been allowed to lead his company? Would that Apple be as successful today?
Jobs didn't want to run Apple - that's why he brought in Scully. Then he got confused.
It was arguably better for Apple and Jobs that they were separate while Jobs re-found his clue.
> Would that Apple be as successful today?
I'd argue that it would have crashed and burned if Jobs had ousted Scully and would have faded if he hadn't brought Scully in.
And even if it doesn't, having a good intuition about people and particular acquaintance with the founder in question are prerequisites to using the technique. A lot of experience with startup founders in particular is also really important.
I think that was exactly the heuristic pg used in this case. He may not think GroupOn is best company in its current form, but he believes that Andrew Mason's smart and driven and is thus capable of evolving GroupOn into a solid and profitable business.