The same as above is true for the root font size discussion, if you set it relative and base the page layout on relative than the user's default font size setting also just turns into a proxy for a full page zoom. Again it's not proof in itself that one is right or wrong it's just that you're either going to stomp on the users default font preference by making it zoom everything instead or you're going to have a design that looks wonky for users with high custom font sizes because the layout wasn't made for big text.
Not necessarily. Zoom text only is meant to change the font size and by extension things that are based off of the font size. Full-page zoom pretends that the browser window is a different resolution (even reporting a different resolution to Javascript) and then scales the page up in the final rendering step. I don't know that the point is necessarily to preserve/change proportions one way or another, they're different algorithms that affect different parts of the page.
This is still a really, really interesting perspective, arguably the most interesting/compelling justification that I've heard on this entire thread as to why a designer might choose to use pixels for width in a normal layout. But even though you have an interesting and insightful take, I'm not sure I buy that the reason designers are ignoring `em` units is to preserve user choice. And in practice in the real world, I notice that the pages that follow an `em`/`rem` philosophy when thinking about column width tend to handle both resizing of text and full-page zoom better.
Let me ask a question; if the goal of full-page zoom is actually to keep the same proportions for its font-size, if that's really the main difference between font-only zoom and full-page zoom, then is it a problem that full-page zoom doesn't affect percentages or viewport width units? Why draw the line specifically at the ratio of font-size to container width? If the point of full-page zoom is to preserve proportions and ratios, shouldn't it act more like zooming a PDF?
Not to preserve user choice in itself no but em isn't preserving user choice in the end either so it's not an argument to convince either side.
It's a problem in the same way your original example was a problem i.e. there is no way to reconcile all of these with good answers consistently so that a certain layout methodology doesn't is proof of nothing. And all options being imperfect leads to the simpler dimension based layout being popular. Of course that means a relative dimension based layout is no more inherently "wrong" just most find it harder to work with and get nothing new they couldn't have accomplished with any other dimension type + the describing CSS syntax.
Percentage/viewport based layouts independently may be an actual "wrong" choice depending what kind of content the page contains. The CSS spec actually reflects that percentage based layout is a unique design choice - em and px are both a "dimension" type and you can make either do the same thing with CSS if you wanted (that doesn't mean just replace em with px and call it a day but it's always doable) whereas percentage and viewport are their own special "percentage" type and you can't make them always behave like another unit type because they actually represent a unique concept.
In short do fun things you just want to understand and you too can sound much smarter than you are when a certain topic comes up :).
Technically yes, but practically no. If you zoom in on a screen, CSS breakpoints based on resolution will trigger. As far as your actual CSS styling goes, you can basically think of the page as having a smaller resolution that then gets scaled up after layout is determined. CSS doesn't have access to the information you're talking about, so it's not valuable to a designer to think in those terms -- at least not unless you're planning to embed a bunch of interface logic in Javascript that doesn't belong there.
The end result is that if you zoom in 200% on an 800px wide viewport, from the perspective of the CSS you're writing you are effectively working with a 400px wide viewport.
> but em isn't preserving user choice in the end either so it's not an argument to convince either side.
This continues to be a compelling argument.
What I will say though is that the more I reflect on it, the more this seems to be an argument for using both `px` and `em` units based on the context of the individual component you are styling. It doesn't seem to be an argument for abandoning relative/point units entirely, as the original article advocates. From the perspective that scaling text alongside containers and scaling text inside containers are both valid ways to scale content, there are going to be some parts of your interface where it makes sense to respond to text size increasing, and some parts that don't.
So for example, I can buy that for a main paragraph, you might want users to have the ability to scale text independently of the column width. But while you're doing that, you probably still want labels to fit inside of buttons. Similarly, you probably don't want the text options on a dropdown menu to overlap with each other and make each other unclickable. And more typographically, you want margins between your paragraphs to remain readable.
So maybe in that scenario if you're maximizing user choice it makes sense to leave you main column in pixels and to only set menus, buttons, and paragraph spacing and margins in `em` units. I could see something like that being reasonable.
The ending of your comment confuses me. I've never heard someone say that percentage-based layouts are explicitly the "wrong" choice, sometimes it does make sense to have a 2-column 50% layout. More specifically:
> `em` and `px` are both a "dimension" type and you can make either do the same thing with CSS if you wanted (that doesn't mean just replace em with px and call it a day but it's always doable)
`em` is a relative size based on the current container's font. So a `4em` sized box means `4 * container_font_size_in_pixels`. There's no way to represent that logic with pixels unless you're using Javascript to change the CSS whenever the font changes. Because `em` units aren't a constant logical unit, they're dependent on the context of the container they're set on.
But if you're going to be updating your layout with Javascript all the time, then you can also absolutely use percentages to get the same layout as pixels as well, they're not a fundamentally different measurement in that scenario. You can have a 1000px container and set all of its children to use percentages, and do all the math to make them line up. You can have Javascript that catches page resizes and readjusts all of its styles.
But if we're talking about the underlying logic, both `em` and percentage units are defined in relation to another unit. They're not equivalent to a fixed value, they scale depending on where they are in the DOM and what those other units are currently doing.
If you're working in pure CSS, there are components you can build that will have behaviors that are impossible to replicate with pixels. If you build a dropdown menu that's using `em` units, it will act differently depending on where it's inserted into the DOM. Pixels won't.
Yeah I'd agree with this as well after all of the thought on it - if you want to really get to the full 100% mixing the units per part of the design as you describe is going to enable a more optimized outcome than any "pure" approach could get to.
The way to make px behave like em in pure CSS is to set dimensions based on a --custom-property so you can do things like width: calc(var(--parents-font-size * 2.5)) or what have you. Bit messier if all you literally want to do is font sized based scaling but also way more flexible to inject other logic into if you want to do more than that. Of course JS can give you even more freedom to change these kinds of things (no restrictions that types have to match and such) but that comes with it's own swath of problems not needed for most anything that isn't a true app-in-a-page.
If my memory serves me right, the default text size is 16px for chrome (not sure about other browsers).
Be it rem, em they are sizes relative to an ancestor. rem being the root ancestor (html selector or browser default), and em being the closest ancestor having an absolute value defined for its font-size property.
Em is great when you want to establish a font size hierarchy in some container for example.
You can test rem by setting media queries defining different font-size values.
You'll see that 1.75rem is always exactly 175% of root element's font-size value.
The problem here isn't whether or not font size eventually at some point in the browser is getting set to pixels -- it's who sets it. Is the browser setting it? Is the user? And is your layout equipped to handle it when it changes?
However, I believe in the most recent version of iOS Safari there will be an option in the left-hand corner of the URL to adjust text size for any page you're on, and Safari will remember that setting on a per-domain basis.
But again, I don't own an iOS device, so I'm not sure exactly what algorithm it uses to resize. It says it's text resizing, but maybe behind the scenes it's doing something different.
It's a difference for anyone who changes the default text size in Firefox. The "Zoom Text Only" option works the same way as Firefox's default text sizing. This is a difference that does matter for anyone who adjusts either the default or minimum font size in their browser, it's not theoretical.
> I like defining the root font size in px and using rem everywhere else
This is better than using pixels everywhere. I would not define a root font size in pixels, I would leave it as 1rem. BUT, what you're doing is much, much better than what the article is proposing, so I'm not going to be too critical.