Agreed. Indeed, most of the rewrites I've seen look like this:
RewriteRule .* /index.php
Are you implying that the front-controller pattern is bad?
No, but mod_rewrite is not the only way of implementing it. In the mentioned case, index.php would implement a front-controller.
mod_rewrite is black magic, and will fail without suggesting why, just throwing a 500 Internal Server Error. Debugging a front controller in PHP (or whatever) it much easier.
It's almost always a better idea to do this another way. Note that the distinction between the "handler" part of the URL, the remaining "path-like" part and the query string is already exposed in the CGI variables (SCRIPT_NAME, PATH_INFO, and QUERY_STRING). The handlers can do this magic on their own. Doing it by placing important application code into the apache configuration for the site strikes me as very confusing.