Re:Ask HN: Why can't anyone tell me what story points equate...
by dragonwriter on Monday March 29, 2021 @11:56PM
(#26631131)
> Contract after contract, engagement after engagement: why can't a single product owner, scrum master, agile coach, anyone, tell me what story points equate to?
Used properly (which not everyone who uses them does, and you can be sure someone isn't of they can't explain this) they are a measure of relative effort that should be linear to working time (what you would log against the work item) to complete, i.e., a 2 sp item should take about 2/3 the staff time of a 3 which should take 3/5 the staff time of a 5.
> And what's with the whole Fibonacci numbers? 1, 3, 5, 8, 13, ..., etc.
> Why can't story points simply mean: time.
Because empirically (and the research on this goes back to the 1940s, IIRC) people, even domain experts, are very, very bad at estimating absolute time of intellectual work (and this gets worse, not better, when break things down into finer-grained tasks and try to rally them up), but aggregating broad-bucket relative-time estimates arrived at by team discussion and scaling by empirical measures of actual velocity works much better.
Fibonacci is to provide the broad buckets.
Unfortunately, it's all become cargo cult detached from rationale.
Used properly (which not everyone who uses them does, and you can be sure someone isn't of they can't explain this) they are a measure of relative effort that should be linear to working time (what you would log against the work item) to complete, i.e., a 2 sp item should take about 2/3 the staff time of a 3 which should take 3/5 the staff time of a 5.
> And what's with the whole Fibonacci numbers? 1, 3, 5, 8, 13, ..., etc.
> Why can't story points simply mean: time.
Because empirically (and the research on this goes back to the 1940s, IIRC) people, even domain experts, are very, very bad at estimating absolute time of intellectual work (and this gets worse, not better, when break things down into finer-grained tasks and try to rally them up), but aggregating broad-bucket relative-time estimates arrived at by team discussion and scaling by empirical measures of actual velocity works much better.
Fibonacci is to provide the broad buckets.
Unfortunately, it's all become cargo cult detached from rationale.