News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:John Gruber Explains Why Free Software Has Poor Usability by ajross on Monday August 04, 2008 @10:38AM (#266289)
This is mostly cheap shot journalism. Sure, there's lots of free software out there with awful interfaces. But there's equally a ton of commercial software that's bad, and for many of the same reasons. Take a look at the crapware installed on any new Dell box, for example.

It's true that at the very high end, the "polish" of commercial software is better. There's no free equivalent to, say, Apple's release and UI artwork processes. But that's not strictly a "usability" critique. There's plenty of beautiful-but-clunky software out there.

Re:John Gruber Explains Why Free Software Has Poor Usability by pauljonas on Monday August 04, 2008 @10:42AM (#266294)
To be expected from the Gruber-bot.

Don't you know? Apple is awesome, and those who criticize them "just don't get it".

I am writing this on a Apple MBP, so it's not like I have total disdain for Apple products, but Apple fanboys can be infuriating…

Re:John Gruber Explains Why Free Software Has Poor Usability by maximilian on Monday August 04, 2008 @12:47PM (#266437)
He doesn't even really mention apple once in his article. He clearly loves most things apple, but he wouldn't hesitate to criticize apple if they do silly things.

Its much more convincing to criticize his argument than just him. He makes a strong point - Software interfaces only are as good as the head guy in charge cares about. So if the head guy doesn't care much about the interface, the interface will suck even if there are great designers working on the project.

I'd say that open source software often has medium to poor interface quality is that making software look good takes a lot of time and has to be done by someone with design talent. This isn't usually the case - usually the lead programmer decided how it would look from the beginning, or just copied some other software.

If anything, open source software is usually decent because they most often just copy some commercial piece of software - which is usually decent. In the few cases where they get creative with the interface (like the gimp) it can come out half-baked because they don't spend enough time evaluating the usability of the design. (not that the gimp interface is half-baked).

Re:John Gruber Explains Why Free Software Has Poor Usability by pauljonas on Monday August 04, 2008 @10:37PM (#267083)
But he's no Mark Pilgrim!