News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gallup: U.S. church membership dips below 50% for first time by ggggtez on Monday March 29, 2021 @04:15PM (#26627605)
No. Because he opens his thought with saying that "Atheism" doesn't exist. Atheism isn't a rejection of "yearning" or "reverence". It's a rejection of religion.

He's just playing word games, and you are falling for it.

Re:Gallup: U.S. church membership dips below 50% for first time by Cookingboy on Monday March 29, 2021 @05:06PM (#26628172)
I absolutely agree. It's just your typical pseudo-intellectualism rant here. It starts with a provocative declaration and then backed up with some explanation that is technically true, but doesn't offer any actual insights or value.
Re:Gallup: U.S. church membership dips below 50% for first time by junon on Monday March 29, 2021 @08:14PM (#26629926)
This was also my takeaway.
Re:Gallup: U.S. church membership dips below 50% for first time by btilly on Monday March 29, 2021 @06:07PM (#26628885)
Correction. Atheism isn't a rejection of religion. It is a lack of belief in God or gods.

The canonical example of the difference is that plenty of religious Buddhists are also atheists.

Re:Gallup: U.S. church membership dips below 50% for first time by aksss on Monday March 29, 2021 @06:53PM (#26629325)
Yes, I know a few atheists whose fervor walks, talks, and quacks like a religious zealot.
Re:Gallup: U.S. church membership dips below 50% for first time by teawrecks on Monday March 29, 2021 @08:29PM (#26630025)
That would be anti-theism, or "strong atheism", though. It's the difference between "not holding any belief related to the existence of a god", and "holding the belief that there is no god".

Not to be confused with "agnosticism" which is "holding the belief that it cannot be known whether there is a god".

Re:Gallup: U.S. church membership dips below 50% for first time by nfw2 on Monday March 29, 2021 @07:53PM (#26629788)
He is playing word games, but he's not trying to trick anyone. When he says atheism doesn't exist, it's just a stylistic flourish. It's not the point of the passage; he's not trying to argue that everyone believes in god.

The point of the passage is that everyone needs a source of meaning in their life, and that religious is more psychologically healthy option than the alternatives.

Re:Gallup: U.S. church membership dips below 50% for first time by mr_toad on Monday March 29, 2021 @09:02PM (#26630235)
> When he says atheism doesn't exist, it's just a stylistic flourish. It's not the point of the passage; he's not trying to argue that everyone believes in god.

‘round here we call that trolling.

Re:Gallup: U.S. church membership dips below 50% for first time by nfw2 on Monday March 29, 2021 @09:35PM (#26630429)
It's not trolling if the audience is intended to see the true meaning. The speech was given to a group of students graduating a liberal arts college. It's a group of people that would appreciate literary devices that don't beat you over the head.
Re:Gallup: U.S. church membership dips below 50% for first time by wellpast on Monday March 29, 2021 @06:19PM (#26629004)
I think you've already fallen for literalness as the only way to interpret or value anything. Which is unfortunate because all of the momentous truths in life (ie, that matter to corporeal beings, to us) are not of the literal variety. You probably know this on some buried level but you cling to the literalness anyway. Why?
Re:Gallup: U.S. church membership dips below 50% for first time by crispyambulance on Monday March 29, 2021 @08:26PM (#26630005)
Dude, you're on HN, what do you expect?

DFW is making a compelling point. The words were taken from his magnificent "This is water" commencement address at Kenyon College in the early naughts.

Re:Gallup: U.S. church membership dips below 50% for first time by nnvvhh on Monday March 29, 2021 @06:03PM (#26628826)
"Just playing word games," he's a writer! Not everything written is documentation.
Re:Gallup: U.S. church membership dips below 50% for first time by acdha on Monday March 29, 2021 @06:11PM (#26628926)
He’s a writer, sure, but that doesn’t mean that bad writing is not fair game for criticism. Redefining words is a common technique in this style of apologetics to avoid having to engage with an argument intellectually and it being used by a famous writer doesn’t make it more worthy.
Re:Gallup: U.S. church membership dips below 50% for first time by Daishiman on Monday March 29, 2021 @07:46PM (#26629732)
No it isn't. I'm sorry but not all writing needs pedants nitpicking to get the point across. The point is extremely clear and you can argue about the nuance but there is no hidden meaning or contradiction here.
Re:Gallup: U.S. church membership dips below 50% for first time by acdha on Monday March 29, 2021 @10:06PM (#26630602)
As evidenced by this entire thread, the point isn't extremely clear _because_ of the writing. I don't think it's just a question of nuance, either, both because he was far too skilled a writer to be unfamiliar with common English vocabulary and it's very much following in a tradition of writing from people who are uncomfortable with wanting to believe in something which they can't justify on the evidence (the very definition of religious faith — see e.g. Hebrews 11:1). Some people react to that by rejecting facts but others take an approach of basically arguing that nobody is purely rational and therefore they can believe what they want, giving them carte blanche to believe things they suspect but don't want to admit are just human creations. As a former fundamentalist, I've seen quite a few examples of that — a very popular one is trying to equate faith or relief in science as being equivalent to their religious counterparts.

Given DFW's history of depression, having rejected his parents' atheism, and having relied on AA in his struggle with addition, I am quite inclined to believe that the latter explanation is true in this case as well. I can understand why he wanted to have a special belief system which would be constructive as a break from the painful destructive behavior he was all too familiar with but that makes it the desperate longings of a broken person rather than a divine truth.

Re:Gallup: U.S. church membership dips below 50% for first time by nfw2 on Monday March 29, 2021 @10:53PM (#26630842)
The point is much more clear when taken in context with the longer speech. When taken out of context it confuses the central point.

The statement about atheists not existing is hyperbole used in passing. He doesn't mean there is absolutely no difference between religious and unreligious people. He means they are often similar in non-obvious ways.

The central point of the full speech is that people should be intentional about what they choose to think and care about. It's not too far from stoicism which seems pretty popular in SV/HN.

The chain of points from this passage back to this central point are:

- Atheists and religious people are similar in that they both have a need to find meaning in their life.

- The alternatives that people find for sources of meaning (power, money, looks, etc) are often psychologically harmful.

- These harmful sources of meaning are often adopted by us unconsciously ("by default").

- It is important to be intentional about what we care about because if we are not, we will default to the harmful sources of meaning.

I agree that there is likely some projection of DFW's own psychological issues onto non-religious people at large, and that a lot of people can live happy lives without some form of veneration.

On the other hand, I think his advice is useful for some. I personally find his message about choosing your values intentionally valuable.

----

Even when taken in context, I admit his writing isn't super clear to a general audience. DFW was fond of experimental writing and also believed that writing should be tailored to the audience. His audience in this case was a liberal arts college, so he may have felt comfortable stretching his use of language.

Re:Gallup: U.S. church membership dips below 50% for first time by acdha on Tuesday March 30, 2021 @01:27AM (#26631487)
> The alternatives that people find for sources of meaning (power, money, looks, etc) are often psychologically harmful.

This why I generally lean towards the “sloppy writing” conclusion — it is indeed useful to consider your values carefully, but trying to dunk on atheists both confused the language and lead to the incorrect claim that religious beliefs are less harmful than secular ones which is easily disproven by talking to people who were mistreated by friends or family members who saw that as a religious requirement (e.g. many gay people) or whose religion embraced the same harmful behaviors (e.g. some state religions or cults, the prosperity gospel, etc.).

Better writing could avoid that distraction by focusing on the common harmful classes of behavior and how to recognize those patterns in any particular system. I don’t see this as experimental language use because it’s so far from novel in this particular context and the net effect is to obscure the point rather than reach some deeper understanding.

Re:Gallup: U.S. church membership dips below 50% for first time by nnvvhh on Saturday April 03, 2021 @10:22AM (#26681309)
Since you are so hung up on denotations, may I suggest a couple of official, sanctioned, orthodox definitions (right up your alley) of words the dwelling upon of which might wrench you from your obstinance: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/connotation and https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/pedantic.
Re:Gallup: U.S. church membership dips below 50% for first time by acdha on Saturday April 03, 2021 @12:41PM (#26682452)
What positive outcome did you expect from a late reply containing nothing of substance? You’ve had 4 days to overcome the initial emotional reaction, why not try for something more?
Re:Gallup: U.S. church membership dips below 50% for first time by nnvvhh on Saturday April 03, 2021 @03:04PM (#26683749)
No substance? Come on now, I thought it clearly communicated my opinion that you were being pedantic in focusing so narrowly on the denotations of English words. Words like "worship" often define fuzzy concepts and do not define things as precise as a function signature. The response to the original quote is so silly to me that I am compelled to continue replying. To ignore the quote's thrust and have your reading be short circuited by its "redefining" of words, especially given that it is a snippet of a wider work, making the initial criticism all the sillier, is too fun to ignore.
Re:Gallup: U.S. church membership dips below 50% for first time by 101011 on Tuesday March 30, 2021 @12:07AM (#26631177)
You are very opinionated for what ultimately is a piece from a fiction writer.

Of course he's going to play on words and conflate emotions when waxing about the meaning of life.

I don't understand why so many have to be such a harsh critic. Yeesh.

Re:Gallup: U.S. church membership dips below 50% for first time by ggggtez on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @08:24PM (#26733450)
If someone is a fiction writer, we shouldn't care what they have to say? Sure. Then let's agree his quote is worthless.

But I'd still argue the opposite. This is a fiction writer who obviously is listened to. He's famous. He's quoted by random people on the internet. And those quotes are taken from speeches that he was presumably paid to give. Words are his profession. It's not correct to say that just because he doesn't do journalism that his words have no impact on reality.

On the contrary, because he is a writer, we should be especially wary of his words. His words are meant to convince you of a point. You can't just ignore his goals and say it's poetry.

His goal is to convince you that Atheism is bad, and he suggests that all atheists worship "something" that will destroy them (since it obviously isn't God, one of the only carve outs he leaves for worship that won't destroy you).

In the context of the above article, the point is crystal clear. The quote was posted with it's intended meaning: that atheists are nothing more than people who "worship" the material. That's bullshit. That's not what atheism is, and Wallace is being disingenuous.

Re:Gallup: U.S. church membership dips below 50% for first time by throwawaygal7 on Monday March 29, 2021 @05:51PM (#26628691)
I mean, theres some truth on both sides.

From a christian/jewish/islamic perspective whatever you focus most on is your 'idol' - the bible talks alot about worshipping money, for instance.

In that sense, then whatever you focus on in life is idolatrous worship, an atheistic religion.

Re:Gallup: U.S. church membership dips below 50% for first time by kriops on Monday March 29, 2021 @06:05PM (#26628850)
"there is actually no such thing as atheism"

There is no truth to that whatsoever.

Re:Gallup: U.S. church membership dips below 50% for first time by meowkit on Monday March 29, 2021 @06:26PM (#26629061)
Hyperbole. Of course atheism exists, but its used as an engaging opener.

Contrary to some other comments in this thread, the people complaining about the literal truth value are the ones falling for the author’s writing technique, not the other way around.

Don’t interpret it literally. Its used to assemble an idea that anything can be worshipped/venerated, not to make the argument that atheism doesn’t exist.

Re:Gallup: U.S. church membership dips below 50% for first time by technothrasher on Monday March 29, 2021 @07:24PM (#26629586)
No, I agree he's equivocating and creating a false dichotomy. Wallace struggled with addiction and alcoholism much of his life, and said that AA was a powerful force in attempting to turn his life around. So it's not surprising that he sees religion and materialistic self-destruction as two sides of one coin. For an atheist who is not particularly self-destructive and content with his choices in life, the quote above reads as not overly insightful outside of explaining Wallace's character.