News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ronald Reagan fires 11,359 air-traffic controllers (1981) by fishtacos on Monday March 29, 2021 @11:37AM (#26623360)
It absolutely is. The courts have their take on it, as expected, but the spirit of a strike remains consistent despite laws against it. A strike, by definition, cannot be illegal. That includes armed forces and every federal employee.

Whether existing legislation recognizes certain types of strikes as legal or not is irrelevant. Civil disobedience has deep roots in American history. This is an analogue to that, given that their rights to strike have been struck. (pun intended)

Re:Ronald Reagan fires 11,359 air-traffic controllers (1981) by ameister14 on Monday March 29, 2021 @12:11PM (#26623988)
Could you explain how a strike cannot, by definition, be illegal?

Civil disobedience can be illegal.

Re:Ronald Reagan fires 11,359 air-traffic controllers (1981) by fishtacos on Monday March 29, 2021 @06:40PM (#26629199)
All civil disobedience is illegal, yet you seem to adjust for some of it vs. others.

Extend that to all employment. Nothing illegal about not being forced to work. A contract is not a prison sentence, or I should hope so.

I will grant you certain conditions apply to armed forces that wouldn't otherwise apply to civilian employment, as that does actively put other's lives at risk. This isn't a conversation about desertion of duty, merely protesting or quitting. Even then there are laws that protect conscientious objectors .

Re:Ronald Reagan fires 11,359 air-traffic controllers (1981) by JamesBarney on Monday March 29, 2021 @01:13PM (#26625014)
Whether existing legislating recognizes a certain type of strike as legal is very relevant to whether or not it is an illegal strike.
Re:Ronald Reagan fires 11,359 air-traffic controllers (1981) by fishtacos on Monday March 29, 2021 @06:41PM (#26629220)
I would argue that from a moral stand point, every strike is legal.
Re:Ronald Reagan fires 11,359 air-traffic controllers (1981) by throwaway0x1 on Monday March 29, 2021 @12:12PM (#26624007)
>A strike, by definition, cannot be illegal. That includes armed forces and every federal employee.

Wrong. A strike, by definition, as actually defined in federal law, can indeed be illegal. That includes armed forces and every federal employee.

Re:Ronald Reagan fires 11,359 air-traffic controllers (1981) by fishtacos on Monday March 29, 2021 @06:44PM (#26629245)
A strike, by definition, cannot be illegal. It's an established form of protest which may or may not lead to firing. Despite the results of the strike, the protest itself is not illegal, nor is walking out of a job. At least from both a moral standpoint.
Re:Ronald Reagan fires 11,359 air-traffic controllers (1981) by fishtacos on Monday March 29, 2021 @11:46PM (#26631076)
*At least from a moral standpoint.
Re:Ronald Reagan fires 11,359 air-traffic controllers (1981) by throwaway0x2 on Tuesday March 30, 2021 @12:34AM (#26631284)
>A strike, by definition, cannot be illegal.

Wrong. A strike, by definition, as actually defined in federal law, can indeed be illegal.

>It's an established form of protest which may or may not lead to firing.

Wrong. It's an established form of protest which may or may not result in criminal fillings because it is illegal federally for federal employees.

>Despite the results of the strike, the protest itself is not illegal, nor is walking out of a job.

Despite the results of the strike, the protest itself is illegal, as is walking out of federal jobs (in a strike).

You literally can't be any more wrong.