Was around both for 10 to 15 years, in computer clubs, ran a punter bbs, worked repairing/selling amigas for years, reliability was awesome, unless one had the rare a bad drive.
Were you lot running 1541s, 71s? Were you living under power lines, beside a power station, and your mom loved fridge magnets? :P
I wonder why the dichotomy. Where I was, it seems the inverse.
Data points re: 1541 reliability:
* all were early adopters, but moved to the Amiga within a year of A500 release. So there is an end-time bracket here.
* I had a VIC20, was an early C64 adopter, and most people I knew were too. So, a start time bracket.
* all drives were bought in Canada
I'm thinking, maybe source plant for drives, PLUS, maybe earlier bought drives were more robust/more expensively made. Fewer cost saving measures?
So hard to tell now. :/
But I remember Dad frequently complaining about reliability, and the drives keep on having to be taken down to a computer shop (back when such things existed) in down-town Lincoln (UK) to be fixed. The problems were entirely mechanical, not electronic.
heck, even my 5.25" c64 drive was so noisy from knocking its head that I kept the cover unscrewed to realign it on a regular basis. especially after trying to use "copy protected" disks that causes even more knocking.
I was also confused when 3.5" floppies came out and were stiff, and people started talking more about "hard disks".