It looks like there are two things going on:
- With the current set of observations, the evidence for clustering is fairly strong, but well short of strong enough that it can't just be chance.
- The new survey was including one data point (which doesn't fit in the 'cluster') that Mike Brown doesn't think counts [1]. With the numbers involved, it seems to me that one additional data point is likely to be making a big difference.
[1] « there is one additional object that Napier et al. include that was never reported to the Minor Planet Center; we restrict our analysis to objects whose detection history we can track; that one unreported object is down in the lower left of the lefthand plot »
It addresses the above a bit and its interesting in its own right talking about Kuiper belt stuff.
I'm not really sure how it's debatable, either their evidence was correct or not. Surely a respectable third person can look and tell us? The mathematics has been out for 6 weeks.
> “It is important to note that our work does not explicitly rule out Planet X/Planet 9"
I find this annoying. If it disproves their evidence, which I assume was the only known evidence for a 9th planet, then it does.
Add to this "Planet X" is tied to the original article, so if this kills all their evidence they also lose naming rights.