Your society failed him on so many levels, and so many times, that it would be a miracle if he didn't land in prison sooner or later.
Fast forward to today, he served his sentence in full and when he got out, he couldn't rent an apartament or find a job. The punishment was supposed to have ended, but it didn't: he has "criminal record", which makes him - in your society - somehow less than a human being.
He somehow lived through this, got a job, wrote a book, started advocating for better prison conditions, started helping inmates in prisons around him.
And now, there's a robdachshund who wants to deny all the good the guy did, want to have him carry a stigma for the rest of his life, and want to take his livelihood from him.
America - I won't ever understand you. I wouldn't want to be a part of a society of such robdachshunds ever, there's not enough money on the whole planet to convince me otherwise.
Society doesn't owe people anything besides freedom, which that guy had, and used it to commit a crime, and paid for it.
> America - I won't ever understand you. I wouldn't want to be a part of a society of such robdachshunds ever, there's not enough money on the whole planet to convince me otherwise.
Guess what, I wouldn't want to be part of a society of self righteous people like you either.
That's one opinion, and it's far from universal even in your country, though it seems to be popular. From the outside perspective, the fact that it seems to be shared by a portion of population this large is deeply mistifying. Edit: I mean, if that's all, then that's a pretty bad deal - a society can tell you to go die in a war, hang you, starve you, make you work to pay for an ever-growing army of officials, and you get out of it just "freedom"?
> and paid for it.
Yes. That's what I said. The OP, though, wants to make him keep paying for it forever. Which is another seemingly popular, yet incredibly disturbing opinion that I can't identify with.
> self righteous people
Thank you, I'll take it as a compliment.
Not american, so not my country even if I live in the US.
> the fact that it seems to be shared by a portion of population this large is deeply mistifying
That portion is shrinking, because we are being infected more and more by the european virus of equality rather than freedom unfortunately.
> The OP, though, wants to make him keep paying for it forever.
If you have killed someone maybe you shouldn't try to become famous and make money out of it, that's what I understood from OP's comment and I agree with that. If nothing else, for your victim and his family/friend.
> Thank you, I'll take it as a compliment.
From your profile I gather you are from Poland, a country that, if I'm not mistaken, has benefited from that american impulse towards freedom in the past. So, what happened here, was freedom ok when it was against communism but not ok anymore now that the USSR is gone? Real question, not trying to be a prick here.
That pretty much explains everything, thank you for your time.
> but not ok anymore
I never said it's not ok, I said it isn't the only thing that a society owes to the people. You failed to explain why do you think "freedom" should be the only such thing.
> Real question, not trying to be a prick here.
If you feel that such a disclaimer is necessary, it would be better to phrase the question differently in the first place.
...
> If you feel that such a disclaimer is necessary, it would be better to phrase the question differently in the first place.
And waste even more time, no thanks.
Now of course, I'm talking in principle here, individual freedom is limited by other things, private property for example, or justice, like in this case with this guy in solitary confinement, but it's because we live in society with other people and we all need to get along, but the principle still remains, freedom is a natural right that precedes society itself.
This was the sense of my comment.
> how being put in jail for transgressions and being free are interrelated?
Jail acts both as a deterrent, through fear of being punished, and it also incapacitates the offender to commit more crime to protect society.
> Who or what determines what is a severe enough transgression to lose your freedom?
It's the people, through laws, who determines what behavior is or is not acceptable in society.
That's different than saying 'he deserves eternal poverty'.
Taking a life is a very, very serious thing.
The sad thing is, _you_ and lots of other compassionate people _think_ prison is about rehabilitation while The majority of the American electorate think it's about punishment.
If this man can never make himself in to more than a criminal, maybe it would be better to just end their life immediately after the crime? A life for a life? If they can bring good out of their evil, should there be a limit to how much good they can bring?
I'm not asking these questions with a specific point in mind, other than to present some additional context.
Nothing specific about the murder yet, though.
This man talks about the stigma of being a felon as being unfair when he took someone's life
I would equate his confinement with torture. However I don't think we should reward him for suffering through a punishment he granted himself.
When a person like this gets ted talks and photoshoots I think we've gone too far. The man has used his crime to turn himself into a brand