Re:String length functions for single emoji characters evalu...
by nerdponx on Friday March 26, 2021 @10:43AM
(#26592738)
Don't Swift and Go support iterating over graphemes? Edit: yes, Swift is mentioned at the bottom of the article.
It'd be great to have a function for that in other scripting languages like Python, Ruby, etc.
There was an interesting sub-thread here on HN a while ago about how a string-of-codepoints is just as bad as a string-of-bytes (subject to truncation, incorrect iteration, incorrect length calculation) and that we should just have string-of-bytes if we can't have string-of-graphemes. I don't agree, but some people felt very strongly about it.
Re:String length functions for single emoji characters evalu...
by banthar on Friday March 26, 2021 @10:48AM
(#26592808)
Defining string as a sequence of unicode codepoints is the mistake.
Nobody ever cares about unicode codepoints. You either want the number of bytes or the width of the string on screen.
UTF-32 codepoints waste space and give you neither.
Re:String length functions for single emoji characters evalu...
by stkdump on Friday March 26, 2021 @02:25PM
(#26595258)
The width on the screen is in pixels. Yes, I find monospace fonts increasingly pointless.
Re:String length functions for single emoji characters evalu...
by anaerobicover on Friday March 26, 2021 @11:59AM
(#26593637)
But what do you do when you're processing a string with codepoints that compose into one user-visible glyph?
>>> len("🇨🇦")
2
Re:String length functions for single emoji characters evalu...
by jxy on Friday March 26, 2021 @03:42PM
(#26596098)
yeah, and what do you do when you got a nonexistent country: "🇩🇧".
Re:String length functions for single emoji characters evalu...
by Symbiote on Friday March 26, 2021 @05:12PM
(#26597002)
Your example changes length depending on the font. (If a new country gets the code DB, fonts will gradually be updated to include the flag.)
I'll bet there are some systems in the PRC that don't include 🇹🇼.
To draw an absurd parallel "[emoji]".len() == 17 is equivalent to [1,2].len() == 8 (2 32 bit integers)
In my opinion the most useful result in the case the article describes is 5. There should of course be a way to get 1 (the number of extended graphemes), but it should not be the strings "length".