Re:Comparing Svelte and React
by chrisz4 on Thursday March 25, 2021 @11:52PM
(#26588590)
Let's step back. I think your approach work really well if you model state machine for internal usage.
However, Redux is meant to be for UI work, which is a side effect. You cannot control side-effect. You cannot guarantee that user will not try to turn switch off twice.
Even in idiomatic Redux, the switch case for reducer always include `default:` which mean everything else go here.
As you said, the Redux FSM models a car lock button interface which is exactly what Redux try model.
However, Redux is meant to be for UI work, which is a side effect. You cannot control side-effect. You cannot guarantee that user will not try to turn switch off twice.
Even in idiomatic Redux, the switch case for reducer always include `default:` which mean everything else go here.
As you said, the Redux FSM models a car lock button interface which is exactly what Redux try model.