Re:Why no downmod for links?
by ichverstehe on Sunday August 03, 2008 @07:26PM
(#265798)
Suggestion: A certain amount of karma is needed to submit links! It's easy enough to get karma through comments. That would probally help a lot on the signal-to-noise ratio.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I don't think low-karma users are the reason for a "bad" signal-to-noise ratio in submissions. I think that with more users, there is simply less consensus on what constitutes signal and what constitutes noise. A karma threshold for submitting wouldn't help with this.
Re:Why no downmod for links?
by benjamincanfly on Monday August 04, 2008 @01:40AM
(#266034)
So the real questions are: how do you get a bunch of anonymous people who don't know each other in real life to decide on the purpose of an already-existing website, and once you've done that, how do you keep the influx of new users in line with the site's stated purpose?
Wouldn't that stop a lot of people from getting involved here too?
Re:Why no downmod for links?
by Prrometheus on Sunday August 03, 2008 @07:56PM
(#265819)
Is a large number of people involved a good thing?
Re:Why no downmod for links?
by benjamincanfly on Monday August 04, 2008 @01:43AM
(#266038)
I'm a little surprised that PG hasn't already capped the number of users.
I think it would be great if user registration happened in seasons. I.e. every three months, there's a 48-hour period during which new people can sign up. The purpose of this would be to allow the site to retain a unique personality. If you constantly add new people, it's hard to know who's who and what we're doing here. Treat it more like a large and semi-exclusive collective, and give it a chance to center itself for a while before expanding again.
Re:Why no downmod for links?
by Prrometheus on Monday August 04, 2008 @07:04AM
(#266177)
I like that idea. It would preserve the egalitarian internet spirit by allowing anyone to join, but prevent waves of new people from joining every time Hacker News gets publicized.