Yeah, but then you're stuck counting lines. Whereas with a mouse, you just click and drag exactly what you want.
"p (vs. right-click > 'Paste')"
This is more difficult if you've copied whole lines but want to paste inside a line or replace text with your paste.
I love me some vim, but I do think it's easy to think we're faster than we are. I wonder if I recorded myself and then watched it if I'd think I was as fast as I feel that I am.
:set relativenumber
> This is more difficult if you've copied whole lines but want to paste inside a line
I agree, but the case where I want to copy multiple lines and have the first line start in the middle of a line is very rare in the languages I use.
> or replace text with your paste
That's what Visual mode is for. Personally, I find pressing Shift-V then j a few times is usually easier for line selection than acquiring the left line-selection margin or finding the end of the text.
In these cases I wouldn't say it's faster as much as I would consistent and easier. I do find myself having to clean up slight mistakes more often with mousing than I do vim commands.
point-click-drag, CMD-X, scroll, point-click, CMD-V
Or for replacing a word at an arbitrary location with other text: scroll, point-double-click, type.
Eschewing a tool for "purity's" sake is not a virtue.
"For scrolling down a couple of pages,"
CTRL-B and j several times (vs. scrollbar/scroll wheel)
"copying 3 lines of code,"
3yy (vs. select block, right-click -> 'Copy')
"moving back up,"
'' (vs. scrolling)
"pasting,"
p (vs. right-click > 'Paste')
"and then changing a couple of characters,"
(depends on the text)
"I actually believe I am faster with a mouse than keyboard, after quite a bit of trying to master vim."
I would humbly suggest the sum of the parts is greater than the whole, especially the use of marks and (unmentioned here) macros or the '.' repeat command.