Re:Phthalates Threaten Humanity’s Ability to Reproduce
by trhway on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @05:57PM
(#26573515)
>accepting transgender folks' identities
that is the issue of social policy (i'm for accepting of whatever identities people have, whether it has scientific basis or not) while the article is supposedly about scientific findings
>obtuse about definitions to some degree
that is my point. It is an science related article and thus it is the context where significant degree of precision and obtuseness with definitions is kind of expected. Slipping in such a blanket imprecise statement is what i tried to point to.
Re:Phthalates Threaten Humanity’s Ability to Reproduce
by sudosysgen on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @06:30PM
(#26573850)
Gender is an issue of social policy, psychology, neuropsychology, and biology. Sex is an issue of science.
That's why science on gender always has small degrees of precision and is obtuse. It's moreso a question of soft science than hard science.
Re:Phthalates Threaten Humanity’s Ability to Reproduce
by caconym_ on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @06:11PM
(#26573669)
I don't really think it's inappropriately imprecise, though. It's just an acknowledgement that the link between biological sex and gender self-identification is not well understood at this time.
Re:Phthalates Threaten Humanity’s Ability to Reproduce
by PurpleFoxy on Thursday March 25, 2021 @07:23AM
(#26578858)
The modern definition of gender reinforces gender stereotypes which are largely arbitrary and obsolete.
It's likely not possible to find widespread agreement on this, but I think the modern concept of gender is more or less about how you align with the traditional male and female roles in society (doesn't have to be in the binary sense). I don't think there's a known right answer for how much of this alignment comes down to "nature", and how much to "nurture". What's clear is that some people do not mentally identify with the sex and/or gender labels and/or roles that their chromosomes would traditionally assign to them.
The "biology doesn't care about your feelings" arguments are stupid because they don't amount to any more than excuses for ignorance—biology obviously can't fully explain gender as in gender roles. In fact, pretty much all the arguments I've seen against accepting transgender folks' identities rely on being obtuse about definitions to some degree.