Re:China's Cell Phone Pirates Are Bringing Down Middle Easte...
by barrkel on Wednesday June 15, 2011 @08:02AM
(#2656719)
I think you're putting words in my mouth: words like "handouts" and "fixed in stone".
But with respect to "spread more widely" that you quote twice, for common resources that is explicitly the goal of democratic government; most efficient use of the resource is not (it might be in anarchy, or oligopoly, or some other system not based on one person, one vote).
Let's not forget that auctions won't necessarily predict the market price; in fact, they're unlikely to, because in this kind of case they rely too much on prediction of future value, and the structure of such licenses will be that they won't trade freely on a market, so normal pricing mechanisms won't work well. There are lots of inherent rigidities: hardware dependencies limit the pace of change. If a government is to get the windfall, it would probably be better (IMO) to tax profits at a later stage.
My perspective is coloured by some of the worse effects auctions of public telco assets had in Ireland; we ended up with telcos deep in debt, owned by foreign private equity (effectively purchased with the company's own debt), starved of revenue to invest and almost completely focused on servicing the debt. I remember at the time the alternative method being used in Sweden[1] and Finland, focused more on so-called beauty contests than auctions.
But with respect to "spread more widely" that you quote twice, for common resources that is explicitly the goal of democratic government; most efficient use of the resource is not (it might be in anarchy, or oligopoly, or some other system not based on one person, one vote).
Let's not forget that auctions won't necessarily predict the market price; in fact, they're unlikely to, because in this kind of case they rely too much on prediction of future value, and the structure of such licenses will be that they won't trade freely on a market, so normal pricing mechanisms won't work well. There are lots of inherent rigidities: hardware dependencies limit the pace of change. If a government is to get the windfall, it would probably be better (IMO) to tax profits at a later stage.
My perspective is coloured by some of the worse effects auctions of public telco assets had in Ireland; we ended up with telcos deep in debt, owned by foreign private equity (effectively purchased with the company's own debt), starved of revenue to invest and almost completely focused on servicing the debt. I remember at the time the alternative method being used in Sweden[1] and Finland, focused more on so-called beauty contests than auctions.
[1] http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0308596105...