News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Video RAM Transplant Doubles RTX3070 Memory to 16GB by Nextgrid on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @06:22AM (#26565408)
They kind of did - there are resistors on the card's PCB to inform the firmware of how much memory is installed and this operation modified them to match the new amount of memory installed.

But beyond that, what would be the reason of spending effort locking this down even more?

Re:Video RAM Transplant Doubles RTX3070 Memory to 16GB by _verandaguy on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @11:45AM (#26568700)
Economic reasons aside — there's historical precedent for Nvidia creating arbitrary limitations in software (and sometimes in dedicated hardware) for their cards.

Famously, many discrete GeForce cards don't play well with virtualized OSes, and there have been some hacky ways to bypass that. This is done because only Quadro cards are blessed by Nvidia to run in "enterprise" environments. Besides this soft lock, there's usually no architectural limitation preventing GeForce cards from working with virtualized OSes if the hypervisor can provide passthrough.

All that to say, it wouldn't be the most shocking news in the world if it turned out they prevent this kind of VRAM modding.

Re:Video RAM Transplant Doubles RTX3070 Memory to 16GB by babypuncher on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @03:21PM (#26571781)
I'm having trouble imagining a world where the cost of this operation is less than the cost difference between a 3070 and an equivalent 16GB card. Buying the ridiculously overpriced 3090 is still going to be cheaper and not come with any of the associated risk (invalid warranty, potential future driver/bios compatibility problems).
Re:Video RAM Transplant Doubles RTX3070 Memory to 16GB by _verandaguy on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @03:53PM (#26572107)
In this specific case, I think it's more about if you can do it rather than if it makes sense. It's a fun challenge, and if you can spare the cash, it does inform the community a bit more about how modern Nvidia cards react to this kind of mod.

A big fraction of Hackaday's content is this kind of fun modding that might not make immediate economic sense.

Re:Video RAM Transplant Doubles RTX3070 Memory to 16GB by baybal2 on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @06:22AM (#26565417)
Prevent market segmentation bypass.
Re:Video RAM Transplant Doubles RTX3070 Memory to 16GB by Nextgrid on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @06:29AM (#26565455)
The effort & equipment required to perform such an upgrade is significant and is very unlikely to be used at scale for defeating market segmentation.
Re:Video RAM Transplant Doubles RTX3070 Memory to 16GB by selfhoster11 on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @07:45AM (#26565921)
I can see that happen as an upgrade service on ebay. It just needs to be priced competitively.
Re:Video RAM Transplant Doubles RTX3070 Memory to 16GB by gruez on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @11:51AM (#26568799)
I don't see the economics working out. You're going to be competing against the 3090, which has 24GB of memory and costs 3x as much as a 3070 (MSRP), but also 78% more shaders. Just to match the 3090's compute capacity is going to cost you $1000 (or $891 if you amortize over multiple cards). That leaves you $500 for the memory chips, labor, and equipment. According to [1], the memory chips cost $12/GB. You won't be able to reuse the existing memory chips, so that means you'll need to buy 16GB of chips for each of the cards, which works out to $384. At this point there's only $116 left, and I doubt anyone would go for this considering that the 3090 only costs $116 more, but has more memory (24 GB), and has full warranty.

[1] https://www.hardwaretimes.com/doubling-graphics-memory-will-...

Re:Video RAM Transplant Doubles RTX3070 Memory to 16GB by baybal2 on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @02:09PM (#26570903)
3090 is largely sold out despite the ludicrous pricetag
Re:Video RAM Transplant Doubles RTX3070 Memory to 16GB by bserge on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @11:57AM (#26568893)
The cost is still going to be high and you risk killing your card. Even if someone offered this kind of service, it would only be taken by a very small number of enthusiasts. So nVidia doesn't care.
Re:Video RAM Transplant Doubles RTX3070 Memory to 16GB by selfhoster11 on Thursday March 25, 2021 @06:45AM (#26578547)
If someone is skilled enough to work on surface-mount/BGA components, they likely already know what they are doing. Board level repair vs board level upgrade is a very similar process (to the untrained eye such as mine, at least).
Re:Video RAM Transplant Doubles RTX3070 Memory to 16GB by baybal2 on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @06:44AM (#26565536)
Well, there is a precedent of graphic cards with modded bios being sold.
Re:Video RAM Transplant Doubles RTX3070 Memory to 16GB by Red_Leaves_Flyy on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @07:29AM (#26565814)
Shhh.