Re:The pandemic has changed the shape of global happiness
by logicchains on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @11:29PM
(#26563249)
There have already been studies that found lockdowns don't help with mortality (which is what matters, not cases), like https://www.thelancet.com/journals/eclinm/article/PIIS2589-5... and https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpubh.2020.6043...
Re:The pandemic has changed the shape of global happiness
by rhino369 on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @11:36PM
(#26563306)
I don't think you need much evidence to believe that lockdowns are temporarily effective. But I'd be curious to see evidence on whether they are effective at reducing overall infections over a longer period.
Because it seems like they just delay (for only a matter of weeks) what is going to happen anyway.
Most of the United States really had two significant waves. NY and other early hotspots never had the summer peak. The summer peak states never had a huge outbreak in spring because they locked down two months.
The states that managed to not have several outbreaks until fall (California and the Planes states) all got hit much worse.
It all seemed to even out.
Re:The pandemic has changed the shape of global happiness
by chii on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @02:17AM
(#26564122)
it evened out because people who were not in lockdown states got infected, and those got transmitted to the states/cities that had been in lockdown but subsequently opened up. In other words, the lockdowns are half-assed.
Re:The pandemic has changed the shape of global happiness
by nl on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @10:56PM
(#26563058)
Exponential spread means small mistakes in containment are difficult to distinguish from an endemic infection - except in the time dimension.
You can see the difference pretty clearly looking at the time series.
But as soon as you open up again infections go up unless you have suppressed the virus completely. Countries that took it seriously did this.
At this point, we probably have well over 100 examples of this. I'm interested if there are any counter examples. Are there?
But on the same hand, there's not any controlled experiments going on. Has this actually been statistically proven?
For example, major populations centers in Florida and Texas had lockdowns for different parts of their spikes. But the states in general were much more lax. And yet, they seemed to have fared similarly to California and New York - which had much more strict local and state-wide measures.