I have fond memories of Digg, at least. Loved the user activism around the HD-DVD key days. That's kind of the last thing I remember was really awesome about that site.
I'd be really curious to see a good analysis or even set of anecdotes about why it went downhill. Seems like basically they ignored their userbase.
MySpace and Digg, now its Facebook and Reddit, what will it be next? HN still seems to be too intelligent for the main-mainstream to invade luckily.