News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Small, cheap spy satellites mean there’s no hiding place by pbronez on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @09:48AM (#26554901)
This is poetic, but I don't think it's true. The world is too complex to model perfectly. It's easy to feel like a digital lens is the whole world, but it really, really isn't. Twitter != Voters

The small sat revolution is a big deal, but much mystery & magic remains.

Re:Small, cheap spy satellites mean there’s no hiding place by scarecrowbob on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @10:51AM (#26555733)
Consider the impact that simply believing the relevant portions of the world has been modeled "well enough".

If magic and mystery is the good thing, then simply feeling like there's no place you can get to which hasn't been mapped might be enough to choke off that feeling, regardless of the resolution of the map.

Re:Small, cheap spy satellites mean there’s no hiding place by pbronez on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @11:17AM (#26556022)
Absolutely. It's self-fulfilling belief. If you believe yourself to be trapped in an exhausted world, then you are. It's usually better to choose an abundance mentality.

The idea that the world has been mapped to the point of killing all mystery is ludicrous. The Map Is Not The Territory[1].

There are mysteries lurking in your own neighborhood that you won't notice until you traverse it in a new way. Go for a walk with a child or dog. Take a bike instead of a car. Use a wheelchair. Volunteer with local advocacy groups.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Map%E2%80%93territory_relation

Re:Small, cheap spy satellites mean there’s no hiding place by photojosh on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @06:17PM (#26561049)
> There are mysteries lurking in your own neighborhood

> Take a bike

I do this... and then I map my discoveries in OpenStreetMap. I recently discovered OpenInfraMap [0] and that inspired me to go find infrastructure that wasn't mapped and add it too.

It works a little in reverse for me; I find a random thing that isn't mapped well and use it as a motivator to go explore it on bike or foot and then map it. I did this for a bunch of local creeks... ran along it, fixed up the errors, and then added all the individual ways to a relation. A lot of places that are accessible by foot only often aren't mapped, so I'll go explore a suburb and find the unmapped paths that shorten foot routes. Making the map better match the territory.

[0] https://openinframap.org/

Re:Small, cheap spy satellites mean there’s no hiding place by colecut on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @12:32PM (#26556927)
“Imagination is more important than knowledge. For knowledge is limited to all we now know and understand, while imagination embraces the entire world, and all there ever will be to know and understand.”

― Albert Einstein

With a little creativity we should never get bored.

Re:Small, cheap spy satellites mean there’s no hiding place by test6554 on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @02:43PM (#26558635)
Imagine a world with so much mapped data that it too needs explorers. Data recorded generations ago that has never been observed by anyone to study it.
Re:Small, cheap spy satellites mean there’s no hiding place by Aerroon on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @07:00PM (#26561444)
We live in such a world. It wouldn't surprise me if most security camera footage is never seen by a human.
Re:Small, cheap spy satellites mean there’s no hiding place by Aerroon on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @07:02PM (#26561463)
There are also mysteries that we can map, but still can't figure out. The weather is one of those - we can map the entire world, but we've yet to be able to create a model at a scale that allows us to make accurate predictions of more than a few weeks.
Re:Small, cheap spy satellites mean there’s no hiding place by Robotbeat on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @03:03PM (#26558926)
Additionally, the increase in space access is increasing the scope of humanity to well beyond the Earth. It may seem ludicrous now, but the same tech that makes cheap satellites possible will open up other worlds, in particular the Moon and Mars.
Re:Small, cheap spy satellites mean there’s no hiding place by t0r0nat0r on Thursday March 25, 2021 @05:01AM (#26577857)
It’s not black or white. OP’s point is still true regardless - as time progresses, things do become more and more mapped. Be it a scientific field, a territory, etc.
Re:Small, cheap spy satellites mean there’s no hiding place by sdht0 on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @03:23PM (#26559205)
I was just reading about the future space missions [0] to the outer solar system already planned within the next couple of decades.

"Whether it’s Dragonfly going to Titan, Clipper going to Europa, hopefully a lander going to Europa, hopefully a mission that’ll fly through the plumes of Enceladus, exo-planets going gangbusters, SETI hopefully taking on a broader and broader search and surveying those exo-planets. Within the next few decades we could potentially answer this primordial, age old question of, “Are we alone?” And that’s gonna revolutionize biology. It’s gonna revolutionize how we think about our place in the universe. And so for all of the pains and agony of trying to operate on these time scales, we do live in a beautiful time where we might transform the universe in which we live into a biological universe."

Along with the commercialization of space travel, I'd say there is a sufficiently large part of this universe we are yet to "touch" but soon will be able to.

I for one am tremendously excited about the future.

[0] https://www.preposterousuniverse.com/podcast/2020/04/13/92-k...

Re:Small, cheap spy satellites mean there’s no hiding place by holoduke on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @04:26PM (#26559977)
More than 90 percent of all galactic systems are moving away from us faster than speed of light. There is no way we can ever reach them. The unreachable horizon is capturing more and more of what we currently observe. https://youtu.be/4iC9Qi3y9q8
Re:Small, cheap spy satellites mean there’s no hiding place by sdht0 on Wednesday March 31, 2021 @06:33PM (#26653996)
Right. To be specific, the whole of the Local Group is available to humanity for exploration. That still has a trillion stars, with at least as many planets.

That's a lot of real estate!

Re:Small, cheap spy satellites mean there’s no hiding place by sangnoir on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @12:46PM (#26557109)
> Consider the impact that simply believing the relevant portions of the world has been modeled "well enough".

That is dangerous belief to those caught-out by the edge-cases, especially seeing how actual humans lazily defer to, and others defend "the (application) system": see any HN thread on AI bias and/or Tesla Autopilots deficiencies.

Re:Small, cheap spy satellites mean there’s no hiding place by jrlocke on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @06:28PM (#26561140)
Consider the things beyond this one planet. Surely we're simply at an interregnum between two great ages of exploration.
Re:Small, cheap spy satellites mean there’s no hiding place by unchocked on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @01:14PM (#26557418)
Indeed. I suspect it's generally true that the more you know, the more questions you have.
Re:Small, cheap spy satellites mean there’s no hiding place by 0xdeadbeefbabe on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @01:10PM (#26557371)
Like how do you make friends who can pay to put one into orbit? Last I checked it was 100K.
Re:Small, cheap spy satellites mean there’s no hiding place by TLightful on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @10:58AM (#26555804)
With respect. The small sat revolution is a load boll@cks.

Forgive me.

Re:Small, cheap spy satellites mean there’s no hiding place by SonicScrub on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @12:36PM (#26556978)
Care to bring up any reasons why you believe the small sat revolution is a load of bollocks? I work in this industry, and can address questions or concerns that you may have.
Re:Small, cheap spy satellites mean there’s no hiding place by salawat on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @12:59PM (#26557251)
I'll bite. Assume every person put a small satellite into orbit, just once. What problems do we have to overcome for what payoff? What revolutionary change do we open the door to?

Sat launch is at best an Engineering issue at this point. More satellites open up avenues for more data collection by well heeled interests, additional burdens on municipalities when the bloody things deorbit, or worse, if they don't. It already obstructs or complicates ground based observation and launch/mission planning/tracking, and adds excessive risk from debris based on current propulsion methods.

It does nothing to advance the State of the Art in manned spaceflight (one of the species more pressing challenges), and it'll become costlier and costlier to get common fuels for rocketry as demand spins down for fossil fuels elsewhere.

I just guess I don't see the point in throwing more autonomous junk into space beyond the minimum necessary to get the job done, or to hyperfocus on any endeavor that doesn't eventually culminate in people in space self-sustainably.

Maybe I've spent too much time mired in Cost-Benefit Analyses recently and it's killed my ability to dream and imagine, but I just don't sea more passive satellites doing what everything else up there already does, but better and with a queue fixing anything; it'd be a boon for launch companies I guess, but do you really need to be in orbitt to solve half the problems people generally throw mini-sats at? I'm not sure the answer is yes.

Love to hear your viewpoint though.

Re:Small, cheap spy satellites mean there’s no hiding place by SonicScrub on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @01:46PM (#26557872)
I think you're downplaying the benefits of more small-sats bring to multiple industries and giving too much weight to certain negative side-effects.

For starters, let's address some of small-sat applications. In you comment you said "I don't see the point... beyond the minimum necessary to get the job done". What job specifically are you referring to? Navigation aids? Communications? Because "the job" that can be handled by small-sats has near unlimited scope. I'm sure you've already heard about LEO communication constellations (such as Starlink) that are bringing world-wide communication infrastructure. Communications infrastructure is a pre-requisite for industrialization, and can greatly assist with providing education to remote areas. Both of these have the potential to lift many of the global poor out of extreme poverty. Communications infrastructure is something that is very easy to take for granted living in a developed first world nation, but the net benefit it provides to society cannot be understated.

People like to focus on the big extravagant projects popularized by eccentric billionaires, but the CubeSat space is filled with other valuable applications as well. Here are some other industry applications that don’t get as much time in the spotlight:

- Resource management / surveying (logging, fishing, mining etc)

- Poaching / illegal fishing detection and monitoring

- Data collection for weather / climate models

- Extreme weather forecasting / detection

- Forest fire monitoring / detection

- Space-based astronomy

- Agriculture monitoring

The above list won't directly impact your day-to-day like the smart-phone revolution did, but that list indirectly touches many aspects of our lives. So again, which “job” are you referring to “getting the job done”? The list above alone (even excluding the comms constellations) could easily require 1000s of CubeSats. The interesting thing about the CubeSat revolution is that because it’s so cheap to send something into space, every possible niche is being explored as industry scrambles to carve out their slice. This comment “but I just don't see more passive satellites doing what everything else up there already does” is not one at all shared within the industry. The CubeSat revolution is doing things that have never been done before. And is doing the things that had been done previously cheaper, faster, and better.

Now let’s talk about the downsides. The space junk and Kessler Syndrome problem is typically brought up in the context of the CubeSat revolution, but it is largely misplaced. CubeSat applications typically require low-earth orbit. In low-earth orbit, atmospheric drag is sufficiently high that junked satellites de-orbit naturally in reasonable time-frames. In addition, placing these satellites into such a low orbit does not create large amounts of junk during launch/insertion. In addition, with space now accessible to more than just government agencies, the appropriate regulatory frameworks for managing space traffic / space junk are being drawn up. The commercial benefits of open, accessible space create huge incentives for governments to manage these issues.

I also see you are disappointed that the CubeSat revolution does nothing to advance manned space-flight. I assure you; this is far from true. In the early days of space exploration, space was very expensive. People focus on launch costs, but it’s much more than that. Supply chains didn’t exist. Nothing was mass manufactured. Everything was custom made. This is changing. The space economy of scale is ramping up, and government-led “for the good of mankind” projects are directly benefiting.

Re:Small, cheap spy satellites mean there’s no hiding place by spockz on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @05:16PM (#26560509)
I’m all for learning how to do space flight better and getting all the regulations in place and getting experience with space launches. The only thing that worries me is whether we will end up in some situation like we are now with plastics that appear everywhere in our food supply chain and are a problem also because the unknown unknowns.

Will we still be able to operate society when we rely so much on all the services provided by These smaller satellites and there is a solar flare. Indeed, what if some event does trigger the Kessler Syndrome. Just like see radiation from Fukushima show at the us west coast in fish.

Will it be too late to do something with all the knowledge we have gained?

Re:Small, cheap spy satellites mean there’s no hiding place by SonicScrub on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @06:29PM (#26561156)
With the CubeSats revolution there aren't a lot of unknown unknowns. The risks are clear, and the benefits far outstrip them. Again, as mentioned above, Kessler Syndrome is of little threat in the low earth orbit which CubeSats operate in.

I don't really understand the argument that coming to rely on CubeSats puts us at risk because they could be damaged by a solar flare. And therefore we shouldn't reap the benefits of this new technology? That line of thinking is like rejecting the advancement of electricity because we will be worse-off in the event of a power outage. Sure, black-out incidents occur, and sometimes (like the recent Texas outage) people are ill-prepared. But how is choosing not to pursue electricity because of black-out risk the better alternative? Surely benefiting from the technology in the far more common scenario of normal operation is better than not having it at all.

Re:Small, cheap spy satellites mean there’s no hiding place by jasonwatkinspdx on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @04:34PM (#26560064)
I swear people watch one highly dramatized movie and think we're something in imminent danger of running out of space up there. We certainly ain't, and it's not like companies don't consider these issues.
Re:Small, cheap spy satellites mean there’s no hiding place by mrzimmerman on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @12:48PM (#26557131)
Do you mind elaborating?