News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Please don't upgrade Docker without asking first by pvorb on Monday March 22, 2021 @08:24PM (#26549364)
But still, if there was no bug in 3.0.2, people wouldn't have tried to downgrade to 3.0.1 again. So the bug was not in 3.0.0, nor in 3.0.1, but only in 3.0.2.
Re:Please don't upgrade Docker without asking first by asidiali on Monday March 22, 2021 @08:43PM (#26549504)
So a user experiences a separate bug in 3.0.2, tries to downgrade to 3.0.1, and is unable to as they are re-upgraded right back to 3.0.2. Do you not consider that a new additional bug, that one is unable to downgrade to 3.0.1, a stable build, at that point? I’d argue that’s a new bug that wasn’t previously discovered.
Re:Please don't upgrade Docker without asking first by pvorb on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @07:10AM (#26553594)
To me the question is, if it's still a bug once the original bug in 3.0.2 got fixed. I'd argue no, you might argue yes.

I think auto-upgrades of Docker are totally fine if it makes the lives of Docker devs easier and they can concentrate on more meaningful things. After all, the majority of the user base is not paying a single cent for the software. If a paying customer complains about auto-upgrades and wants to buy into their own support branch, that's a different story.

Re:Please don't upgrade Docker without asking first by asidiali on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @10:21AM (#26555347)
Thanks for elaborating, yes, I think we probably just disagree on that part. What if someone upgrades and they just don’t like the new functionality of 3.0.2 and they want to go back to 3.0.1 just because? This idea that bug-free releases would prevent downgrades is simply unrealistic IMO - as another comment pointed out, why even have versions then?
Re:Please don't upgrade Docker without asking first by pvorb on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @05:00PM (#26560339)
I understand your position, but the example here feels a bit off. If we were talking about an auto-upgrade from 2.x.y to 3.0.0 I'd probably agree with you. For a minor version upgrade maybe, too. But why would I want less bugfixes for the exact same feature set? Yes, there was a bug in a fix. But as soon as that's fixed, everyone should be fine.

I've no idea if Docker's auto-upgrades also include minor an major versions, though.

Re:Please don't upgrade Docker without asking first by asidiali on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @07:15PM (#26561582)
That’s a good point, I think that makes sense. Maybe not a good idea for larger releases like you said, but yeah for bug patches, why wouldn’t I want those. That’s fair.
Re:Please don't upgrade Docker without asking first by lopatin on Monday March 22, 2021 @08:40PM (#26549476)
> people wouldn't have tried to downgrade to 3.0.1 again

What's the point of having versions if you can't install them?

Re:Please don't upgrade Docker without asking first by pvorb on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @02:01AM (#26564056)
There's a point for the developers and to communicate features and bugfixes. And they still help in supporting installations. But you are correct, they become less important. They (patch versions at least) don't necessarily have to be communicated to users.