News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sovereign writers and Substack by michaelt on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:05PM (#26542722)
> [...] writers who can command a paying audience have heretofore been significantly underpaid.

I don't know for sure, but I suspect the writer-paid-monthly model is straight up more effective at pulling money from readers' pockets than the magazine subscription model.

I mean, I can pay £34 a year for a fortnightly magazine with quite a few writers doing quite a lot of investigative journalism, and even mailing a paper copy to me. I can pay £10 for a novel by a bestselling author who takes several years to write each novel.

But with the market positioning of "$10 per month" it turns out you can sell one person's writing for £86 ($120) per year.

Strange that the output of one full time human writer could be priced so differently, even when every example is award-winning and well known. Perhaps the future of writing is a return to Dickens-era serialisation, and the next J. K. Rowling will be posting two chapters a week on Patreon.

Re:Sovereign writers and Substack by abhinav22 on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:19PM (#26542919)
I think once the novelty wears off and people start seeing how many subscriptions they are on, they will move to consolidated packages covering multiple writers, like Netflix for writing. Which already exists in the sense of Medium.com

Everything reverts to the mean and your point is valid - we shouldn’t expect one form of writing to have abnormally high returns to effort ratio for too long, unless there is a general shift in the value of writing by the population at large. Which given current trends towards video and higher stimulation, I would assume is less likely?

Unless one could argue there’s a huge untapped latent market of bookworms. I think there is some market to a degree as people get burned out on other forms of media, but I’m not sure if it’s large enough for substacks model to work for a significant period in the future

Re:Sovereign writers and Substack by ghaff on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:26PM (#26543009)
I could absolutely see an aggregator model, where the quasi-publisher maybe even provides some degree of editorial support at the copyediting level. The question then becomes though if the $100 or so/year which still seems to me to be the ceiling for something like this is sufficient to support a stable of writers.
Re:Sovereign writers and Substack by abhinav22 on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:35PM (#26543143)
I guess how different will that be to the current subscription model for premium newspapers like WSJ, NYT, FT etc?

Perhaps it could result in the rise of “micro magazines” where a few writers combine and create their own joined content vs being forced to being part of a larger bureaucratic organization.

Or readers could pick and choose a selection for their bundle.

Definitely can expect to see some disruption in the market!

Re:Sovereign writers and Substack by ghaff on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:56PM (#26543423)
It's different in that there's a different level of editorial control--though it's not that different from the op-ed page.

There are other examples, albeit ad-supported ones. One of the tech pubs used to have a blog network of outside writers. (They eventually dropped this as they became less and less comfortable with outside people writing under their brand; this was also a period when orgs were pulling back from their own people having strong personal brands on their sites.) Back to the print days, many tech pubs had a stable of regular columnists. A lot of Forbes blogs are third-parties.

It's not an unreasonable model. The question, as with many things, is what the economics look like.

Re:Sovereign writers and Substack by ghaff on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:18PM (#26542906)
How many people will actually pay $120/year though. I pay in that ballpark for the NYT and The Economist. But it seems borderline nuts to pay that for a single author's newsletter unless they're delivering unique insights that I can turn into a lot more money than that. Or maybe is they do a really good job of covering a niche hobby although that's still almost certainly more than a niche hobby magazine would charge.
Re:Sovereign writers and Substack by rchaud on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @11:21AM (#26556065)
This is why I feel subscription-based commerce does not take consumer psychology into account. They've seen it work for Netflix, so why shouldn't it be exactly the same for words on a screen?

Like you, I'm happy to pay for a physical product that creates a sense of wholeness. A book is time-bound and content-bound. It has a start and an end. A magazine subscription is similar. A physical product, plus you know what you'll be getting over a one-year timeframe. That kind of bounded-ness helps me mentally assign value to a product.

A Substack subscription on the other hand feels like a monthly retainer for a service I don't attach the same kind of value to.

Re:Sovereign writers and Substack by rahimnathwani on Monday March 22, 2021 @06:25PM (#26548165)
"Perhaps the future of writing is a return to Dickens-era serialisation, and the next J. K. Rowling will be posting two chapters a week on Patreon."

This is how online literature works in China: https://archive.is/uoOXS