Everything reverts to the mean and your point is valid - we shouldn’t expect one form of writing to have abnormally high returns to effort ratio for too long, unless there is a general shift in the value of writing by the population at large. Which given current trends towards video and higher stimulation, I would assume is less likely?
Unless one could argue there’s a huge untapped latent market of bookworms. I think there is some market to a degree as people get burned out on other forms of media, but I’m not sure if it’s large enough for substacks model to work for a significant period in the future
Perhaps it could result in the rise of “micro magazines” where a few writers combine and create their own joined content vs being forced to being part of a larger bureaucratic organization.
Or readers could pick and choose a selection for their bundle.
Definitely can expect to see some disruption in the market!
There are other examples, albeit ad-supported ones. One of the tech pubs used to have a blog network of outside writers. (They eventually dropped this as they became less and less comfortable with outside people writing under their brand; this was also a period when orgs were pulling back from their own people having strong personal brands on their sites.) Back to the print days, many tech pubs had a stable of regular columnists. A lot of Forbes blogs are third-parties.
It's not an unreasonable model. The question, as with many things, is what the economics look like.
Like you, I'm happy to pay for a physical product that creates a sense of wholeness. A book is time-bound and content-bound. It has a start and an end. A magazine subscription is similar. A physical product, plus you know what you'll be getting over a one-year timeframe. That kind of bounded-ness helps me mentally assign value to a product.
A Substack subscription on the other hand feels like a monthly retainer for a service I don't attach the same kind of value to.
This is how online literature works in China: https://archive.is/uoOXS
I don't know for sure, but I suspect the writer-paid-monthly model is straight up more effective at pulling money from readers' pockets than the magazine subscription model.
I mean, I can pay £34 a year for a fortnightly magazine with quite a few writers doing quite a lot of investigative journalism, and even mailing a paper copy to me. I can pay £10 for a novel by a bestselling author who takes several years to write each novel.
But with the market positioning of "$10 per month" it turns out you can sell one person's writing for £86 ($120) per year.
Strange that the output of one full time human writer could be priced so differently, even when every example is award-winning and well known. Perhaps the future of writing is a return to Dickens-era serialisation, and the next J. K. Rowling will be posting two chapters a week on Patreon.