News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by andybak on Sunday March 21, 2021 @05:16PM (#26534154)
Well yes. But anyone can make a reproduction of a Warhol print. But there is a chain of custody that adds value.

I'd like to reiterate that I think the value in a Warhol print is also stupid. It's less stupid than NFTs but the point I'm trying to make (apparently unsuccesfully) is that these differences are matters of degree rather than type.

We humans have a multitude of ways to invent value that is built on sand.

Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by ori_b on Sunday March 21, 2021 @06:01PM (#26534533)
> Well yes. But anyone can make a reproduction of a Warhol print

The point is that an NFT only shows a chain of custody for the NFT. It does not imply anything about the originality of the Warhol.

Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by andybak on Sunday March 21, 2021 @06:11PM (#26534621)
See my other comments throughout this thread.

We have many fictions we indulge in about authenticity and value.

NFTs are a new fiction. They might even be dumber than other currently accepted fictions.

But the discussion is "which of these fictions is the most stupid?" rather than "NFTs are stupid". We are already a long way from genuine utility or intrinsic value and into the realms of social consensus and value-through-association.

Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by ori_b on Sunday March 21, 2021 @07:18PM (#26535048)
Sure. They have value because people will pay.

I still suspect most people think they're getting an exclusive license for a piece of artwork, and not a bit of performance art.

They almost certainly believe that the goods pointed to by the token are non-fungible. Not that they have a non-fungible reference to a fungible good.

Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by andybak on Sunday March 21, 2021 @07:39PM (#26535170)
Oh I definitely agree. People are very confused about what they're buying. And many people involved have no incentive to correct that misapprehension.

It's quite a shabby business in many ways.

But that just makes it even more akin to the mainstream fine art market.

Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by roywiggins on Monday March 22, 2021 @04:04PM (#26546116)
Can they? A proper reproduction would involve replicating Warhol's screen-printing process exactly. Probably easier than painting a replica Picasso, but... still pretty involved.

Minting an NFT is trivial, you can do it with the press of a button, at scale. You could mint an NFT for every single item in the Library of Congress with a for-loop, if you could pay the transaction fees.

Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by andybak on Monday March 22, 2021 @04:41PM (#26546679)
OK but I doubt that Warhol's fame rests on his exceptional screen printing skills.

I get your point but I'm sure we could swap out another example that illustrates the point a little better.