News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon Tells States: 'Drop Dead' Over Sales Tax by protomyth on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @11:17AM (#2653343)
It is burdensome to track sales taxes in every part of the country. It is much harder than keeping track of 50 values. I actually wish that sales tax was determined by the origin of a package and not the destination.
Re:Amazon Tells States: 'Drop Dead' Over Sales Tax by wiredfool on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @11:46AM (#2653478)
It's not just 50.

Every locality in Washington state potentially has a different sales tax rate. And, Washington just changed their rules so that the sales tax for instate merchants is not based on where the merchant is located, but where the customer is. So, for every small business that does any business other than through a physical storefront, they need to go based on (at the very minimum) the zipcode. (http://taxrates.dor.wa.gov).

And that's just Washington State.

Re:Amazon Tells States: 'Drop Dead' Over Sales Tax by protomyth on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @12:28PM (#2653641)
ick, I edited out a clause - I was trying to say their are more than 50 values because of all the different rules and localities - learn to proof I guess.
Re:Amazon Tells States: 'Drop Dead' Over Sales Tax by miccotech on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @11:42AM (#2653468)
Burdensome is an understatement. Between cities, counties and states levying sales tax, there are thousands of taxing entities. In some cases, it's impossible to determine the proper tax rate without a nine-digit zip since city boundaries may split zip codes, meaning city+county or just county might apply in different parts of a zip code area. Forcing the customer to enter a nine-digit zip and then possibly choose between multiple tax options when it's still not clear leads to an incredibly high friction checkout. The main winners in this fight are the companies that provide sales tax computation components or APIs for web services.

However, I think having a sales tax based on location of seller rather than buyer doesn't make as much sense. The big companies like Amazon would find loopholes that allowed them to originate from low/no tax areas and smaller sites without the ability to relocate would be stuck with most of the burden. This just changes the fight from big box vs. internet to small site vs. big site.

Re:Amazon Tells States: 'Drop Dead' Over Sales Tax by stonemetal on Tuesday June 14, 2011 @01:21PM (#2653852)
In Texas there is a state wide sales tax of 6.25%. Local taxing jurisdictions(cities, counties, what have you) may charge up to 2% more. So you could have 50 different tax rates in Texas before you consider any other state. Who wants to follow politics in every town in Texas just to see if they adjusted the tax rate. Even if it is feasible for Amazon it isn't for every web retailer.