News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by vvanders on Sunday March 21, 2021 @03:58PM (#26533401)
> (Leaving aside the carbon emissions - let's assume everyone finally switches to Proof of Stake)

I don't know how you get to defend something when you're sidestepping the biggest problem with NFTs.

I'm fine with stupid and pointless things as long as your stupid and pointless things don't wreck the environment. If someone decides to poison the local water supply because it's an "art project" they still poisoned the fucking water supply.

Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by andybak on Sunday March 21, 2021 @04:01PM (#26533428)
Well - Proof of Stake NFTs are already here: https://www.hicetnunc.xyz/

So all I'm doing is hoping everyone uses these instead.

Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by dmitryminkovsky on Sunday March 21, 2021 @04:10PM (#26533516)
Thanks I've been looking for a PoS blockchain in production. Will check this out. Do you know any others?

I really enjoy NFTs conceptually, much more than crypto in general actually, and I really don't get a lot of the hate. If you remove the emissions aspect (which is the non-starter for me), I think it's so cool that there is a way to create scarcity in the digital world, even if that scarcity is totally "meaningless." Yes, there are some goods with inherent value: food, shelter, heat sources. But NFTs are far from the first type of asset that has no inherent value, and that includes both the cyber and real worlds. Humans like to curate and collect, and NFTs are just an expression of that drive.

What I wonder if why NFTs suddenly took off now. I remember hearing about them years ago.

Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by dgellow on Sunday March 21, 2021 @05:37PM (#26534320)
> I've been looking for a PoS blockchain in production

Tezos, Cardano, Algorand just to mention a few of them.

Example of creating an NFTs using Algorand: https://developer.algorand.org/tutorials/create-and-manage-n...

Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by incrudible on Sunday March 21, 2021 @05:47PM (#26534407)
Cardano is a production proof-of-stake blockchain. It has the fifth-largest market cap.

However, Ethereum has virtually monopolized the DeFi space. It is supposed to move to PoS, especially considering that transaction fees are insanely high due to recent demand.

Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by bathory on Sunday March 21, 2021 @06:21PM (#26534675)
You can't even run a hello world on cardano yet. but it has that market cap, with the expectancy that all users who buy in now will become super rich soon (Tm)
Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by jebeng on Sunday March 21, 2021 @06:07PM (#26534592)
It's weird for me to read HN and see people speak of PoS as some kind of new cutting edge technology. Maybe some of the issues with it may or have may not been solved but it is so damn old now that it's 2021.

Like the first live real money implementation of a PoS chain was done by SunnyKing back in like...I want to say 2012, but maybe 2013. SunnyKing was the same guy who went on to make the somewhat interesting PoW function via finding largest prime numbers(arguably somewhat useful PoW, certainly more than double SHA-256), Primecoin.

Then in a larger scale there was NXT which was like 2013-2014ish, full PoS.

I don't care about the merits of these particular chains, but PoS was one of the earliest innovations in blockchain tech. The lineage was roughly something like:

0. All the centralised pre-Bitcoin cypherpunk digital currency stuff from the mailing list like Bitgold, Chaumian ecash whatever.

1. Bitcoin

2. Namecoin(decentralized DNS)

3. Feathercoin/Litecoin(Bitcoin with 0.25 block target time and 4x total coins), arguably shouldn't be on the list for 'innovation' but Litecoin is successful(at some point they changed the PoW work function to scrypt so I guess it counts, there were other scam coins around this time too doing the same thing. So I don't necessarily mean Litecoin was 'third place' overall, just that it ended up rising from the pile of shit).

4. Different forms of PoW functions. ie Litecoin doing scrypt so people could still use their ATI Radeon 4xxx to mine and not order ASICs from shady companies), Cryptonight stuff maybe(lies about it being 'developed on the darknet for years and being related that cicada thing' before and such, hard to make an accurate timeline for that one(ended up forked off as Monero, possibly post-PoS tech)).

5. PoS, 2012-2014ish. Probably didn't come before different PoW functions but it might have switched with #4's place, hard to remember the exact timelines, but people were trolling and making fun of PoS ever since it was theorized. Probably because a true fully realized PoS that is superior to PoW is a threat to the massive investments one must put behind PoW systems, which also becomes the root of their 'nothing at stake' arguments against PoS, which certainly had merit back then with early PoS implementations. I wonder if those truly got solved.

This was all like 2014 at the latest. Very old stuff but crypto is full of sales snakes(not targeted at you at all) who try to sell other peoples old open source tech as new modern innovations. It's a familiar pattern. People sold Bitcoin as private and anonymous for years...like way too long.

I'm imagining now there will be a point when PoS is 10+ years old and people will acting like it's the newest thing on the block still.

Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by krupan on Sunday March 21, 2021 @08:40PM (#26535515)
Are we assuming that no energy will be used to acquire coins in order to stake?
Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by brandonmenc on Sunday March 21, 2021 @07:46PM (#26535206)
> I don't know how you get to defend something when you're sidestepping the biggest problem with NFTs.

Does crypto have a (significantly) larger carbon footprint than video games? Probably not. I think video games (and crypto) are pointless. ymmv.

Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by Symbiote on Sunday March 21, 2021 @08:05PM (#26535317)
Per entertained / occupied (whatever) person, crypto has an orders-of-magnitude bigger footprint.
Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by risho on Sunday March 21, 2021 @04:02PM (#26533436)
nft's don't poison the environment in and of themselves. First of all they don't NEED to exist on a proof of work blockchain, and second whether or not you make or trade nft's people are still going to be mining bitcoin and ethereum. your criticism here is of proof of work, not nft's. please don't conflate the 2. there are plenty of reasons that nft's are silly, but proof of work isn't one of them.
Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by vvanders on Sunday March 21, 2021 @04:10PM (#26533511)
Until NFTs move away from proof of work I'll continue to criticize them.

It's like expecting good intentions and then being surprised when a few bad actors ruin things for the larger group. Tragedy of the commons is exactly why stuff like this should be called out, each and every single time.

Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by andybak on Sunday March 21, 2021 @04:25PM (#26533650)
Which is why I tried to limit my discussion to PoS. Which (I'll repeat myself here) already are being used for NFTs.
Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by kvz on Sunday March 21, 2021 @05:46PM (#26534391)
Ethereum is switching over to proof of stake this year which will pretty much solve the environmental issue
Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by krupan on Sunday March 21, 2021 @08:44PM (#26535551)
You seem to assume that very little energy will be spent to acquire coins for staking. If there is real interest in ether and stiff competition to stake (and there better be for proof of stake to work), I'm afraid that won't be the case.
Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by solveit on Sunday March 21, 2021 @10:11PM (#26536126)
At that point that's just energy spent on acquiring money though.
Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by krupan on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:14AM (#26536795)
So that won't harm the environment, but bitcoin proof of work will?
Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by solveit on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:34AM (#26536894)
It will harm the environment, but no less than the rest of our economy. There are two problems being conflated here. In basically all of society, people harm the environment in order to acquire resources. In proof of work, you go one step further and proceed to destroy the resources you just acquired. This is because destroying resources via reversing hashes is a costly signal that cannot be faked and is hence not susceptible to a Sybil attack.

Proof of Stake doesn't have this problem. The mere act of owning a coin does not entail the destruction of value. In proof of stake, you just make money, probably harming the environment along the way as you do, and buy the coin. That's it. The resources you obtained are not destroyed, they are passed on to whoever you bought the coins from.

Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by krupan on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @10:49AM (#26555705)
In both proof of work and proof of stake people are doing work (using energy) in order to obtain money.

In proof of work you work to obtain mining equipment and electricity and then use that to perform the work of securing the network (nothing is “destroyed”). You are then paid for doing that work. The more work you do relative to other miners, the more you will get paid.

In proof of stake you work to obtain eth (for example) which then grants you the privilege to run validators. The more you stake, the more validating you can do. You are paid money for successfully validating, and charged money for failing to validate. You will need to do more work to replenish money spent on unsuccessful validation. Ultimately, the more work you do relative to other stakers, the more you will get paid.

It’s going to be a little more difficult than it is for proof of work to measure how much total energy is used by proof of stake, but it still should be doable. Maybe it will be less than the energy used by proof of work, but maybe not.

Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by runeks on Sunday March 21, 2021 @04:20PM (#26533595)
> I'm fine with stupid and pointless things as long as your stupid and pointless things don't wreck the environment.

I hang up decorative lights around Christmas time. Is that not okay with you, or do you not find it pointless?

Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by vvanders on Sunday March 21, 2021 @04:29PM (#26533691)
If your Christmas lights used the same amount of electricity as the whole town? Maybe.

Thankfully we have an amazing new technology called Light Emitting Diodes so we don't have to worry about that theoretical problem.

Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by krupan on Sunday March 21, 2021 @08:41PM (#26535524)
LEDs still use electricity. Are you in charge of setting the limit on how much use is acceptable?
Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by Twisell on Sunday March 21, 2021 @06:29PM (#26534739)
I think in 1-2 generations people will look back and wonder about how dumb we were about our energy consumption regarding the environmental challenges we were facing.

Most of ou current Christmas folklore is pretty pointless lights being a pretty recent invention when compared to christian religion timespan. Same as for Christmas trees, they were pretty much on point when everybody had a wood stove to throw them in after Christmas and warm the house. Pretty pointless nowaday when you live in a flat...

Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by madrox on Sunday March 21, 2021 @04:32PM (#26533716)
Do you play video games, then? Because arguably it isn’t NFTs that consume power...it’s the GPUs. GPUs do way more than NFTs, and there is data that shows that gaming consumes way more than blockchain.

If my mom is any indicator, many consider video games stupid and pointless. Value is in the eye of the beholder.

Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by kllrnohj on Sunday March 21, 2021 @05:44PM (#26534380)
A quick search finds that a single bitcoin transaction consumes around 773.80 kWh. That's enough to power a video game console, like a PS5 for example, for around 3100 hours. So the simple act of buying the video game to play would cost vastly more electricity than playing it ever will.

Whether or not gaming as a whole consumes more power than crypto as a whole isn't the question, it's whether or not crypto would consume more power per person using it than per gamer playing games. As in, give everyone a ~fixed power consumption quota - where is that power "better" spent, gaming or crypto?

Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by madrox on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:03AM (#26537638)
I honestly don't know where the power is better spent. There are quite a few industries I personally find superfluous in the world according to my personal set of values. Ironically for this context, I consider bitcoin to be among them.

But I also don't think judging the industry on power consumption is particularly fruitful, unless we want to look industry-by-industry and weigh utility vs energy, which we do not do. We do this for blockchain because calculating this is easy. We don't even have these numbers for, say, the stock market, so we don't even know how good or bad that is. We can't answer the first questions that arise from this kind of analysis.

Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by kllrnohj on Monday March 22, 2021 @10:15AM (#26541082)
> We don't even have these numbers for, say, the stock market, so we don't even know how good or bad that is. We can't answer the first questions that arise from this kind of analysis.

Crypto isn't competing against the stock market, it's competing against something like Visa. And we can answer that comparison: https://www.statista.com/statistics/881541/bitcoin-energy-co....

1 bitcoin transaction takes more power than 100,000 Visa transactions.

> But I also don't think judging the industry on power consumption is particularly fruitful, unless we want to look industry-by-industry and weigh utility vs energy, which we do not do.

That's exactly what I think we as a society should do. We are limited on the amount of sustainable power generation, so looking at cost vs. value is exactly what we should be doing. Especially when something comes along that does the same basic thing as an existing system, but 100,000x more expensive.

Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by vvanders on Sunday March 21, 2021 @05:07PM (#26534056)
If you want to bring the data you mentioned we can have a conversation, however I would be very surprised if it came close to the 50-130GWh mark for just bitcoin alone[1].

[1] https://cbeci.org/

Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by madrox on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:51AM (#26537574)
These are the sources I've used when I've gone looking, but it doesn't help that we don't actually do industry-by-industry energy consumption comparisons.

[1] https://www.researchgate.net/publication/257768246_Electrici... - US energy consumption by video game consoles in the US alone was 16 TWh in 2010

[2] https://grist.org/article/video-games-consume-more-electrici... - Globally, PC gaming (not console gaming) was estimated at 75 TWh in 2018

Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by mouldysammich on Sunday March 21, 2021 @05:07PM (#26534054)
Maybe this is a the case, however there are, I would guess at least a billion people on earth who play games. there is nothing even close to that using blockchains. If blockchain energy usage is even vaguely in the range of games it can still be considered an enormous --possibly-- unnecessary usage of power
Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by madrox on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:57AM (#26537609)
Maybe this is the case, but when we start judging what constitutes unnecessary usage of power, we get in the business of telling people what they can and cannot do with hardware they own. Last I checked, the HN crowd really doesn't like that kind of thing.
Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by hatboxreappoint on Sunday March 21, 2021 @04:38PM (#26533752)
> there is data that shows that gaming consumes way more than blockchain

Source?

Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by madrox on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:52AM (#26537579)
These are the sources I've used when I've gone looking, but it doesn't help that we don't actually do industry-by-industry energy consumption comparisons.

[1] https://www.researchgate.net/publication/257768246_Electrici... - US energy consumption by video game consoles in the US alone was 16 TWh in 2010

[2] https://grist.org/article/video-games-consume-more-electrici... - Globally, PC gaming (not console gaming) was estimated at 75 TWh in 2018

Re:John Cleese Sells the Brooklyn Bridge as an NFT by andybak on Sunday March 21, 2021 @04:45PM (#26533814)
If I had to bet I would probably bet that "all the gamers in the world" are using more power than "all the crypto miners in the world".

I can't think of a way to immediately gather any evidence for this either way but it seems like a plausible position to take.

(However - I think the value > utility chain is easier to argue for with gaming. I'm not making the same argument as the parent post.)