But, sorry if you think trying to avoid illness, trying to avoid passing on illness to others who don't have the comfort of working from home, passing on the illness to elderly family members, etc, is a waste of time. It's a pretty minor inconvenience for me to be largely isolated for a year, compared to those who are less fortunate than me.
How about a big 'ol [citation needed] on
> All current data shows areas that have taken that approach are significantly better off today than the places that hid in a hole the past year.
You know, a citation that doesn't involve correlation with countries that happened to have extreme lockdowns initially, acceptance of mass testing and screening and social restriction when necessary, etc.
By the way, my wife works in rehab in a hospital, and sees your "low risk" young people whose lives have been, as far as we can tell, permanently altered by the virus that some of us are seeking to avoid.
My uncle is in the hospital in pretty bad shape, on oxygen so far. He was spewing conspiracy shit non-stop on facebook. My father urged him to take the vaccine, then to come to the hospital sooner, he did a CT scan on my uncle, told him, showed him how messed up his lungs were, my uncle refused to be administered in the hospital, made a big fuss that the doctors wanted to kill him in the ICU; two days later he was brought in in an ambulancr.
If he was a stranger, maybe I would have laughed "serves you right", I just cannot understand how an above average intelligence person got himself brainwashed with anti-covid conspiracy theories.
> The districts, large and small, rural and urban, serve more than 2.2 million students across the United States. Of the 74 districts that responded, 74% reported multiple indicators of increased mental health stresses among students. More than half reported rises in mental health referrals and counseling. Nearly 90% of responding districts cited higher rates of absenteeism or disengagement, metrics commonly used to gauge student emotional health
https://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/health-c... (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26532588)
Source?
I'd argue current data shows that those that showed an overabundance of caution, like New Zealand, are the ones significantly better off than everyone else.
We didn't even shutdown widespread commercial traffic between the US and Canada (although otherwise travel was largely shut down).
???
> We didn't even shutdown widespread commercial traffic between the US and Canada (although otherwise travel was largely shut down).
Why bother? It’s not like any significant number of transmissions are coming via commercial transit with Canada. I don’t pretend to be an epidemiologist but it seems pretty intuitive that a small island nation and one of the largest countries are going to differ.
You mean an island nation with strict control over their ports and borders?
But does that truck driver need to have direct contact with other people to do their job? Why can't they unload their cargo, sleep at a quarantine facility, and then drive a new truckload in the opposite direction, without an opportunity to infect anyone else?
Also, island nations still have internal traffic. What's different about the borders between parts of Australia that allowed them to be closed when European borders had to stay open?
All countries with quarantine facilities I'm aware of are using existing buildings. They don't have to be hermetically sealed, just ensure that people don't come into contact with each other inside.
Australian states' borders aren't like those between New York and New Jersey (or Colorado and Wyoming), or Belgium and the Netherlands. There are a handful of highways that can be and were completely blockaded, and otherwise the borders are completely empty desert. (Even on the highways, there are dire warning signs about having sufficient water/gasoline/supplies in the more remote parts.)
Internal traffic among 4 million people is a much easier problem than traffic among a continent of 800 million people.
> But does that truck driver need to have direct contact with other people to do their job?
I’m sure there are better ways to do things, but truck drivers often unload shipments, confirm receipts, etc and they still need to visit truck stops and restaurants for supplies, food, etc.
> Why can't they unload their cargo, sleep at a quarantine facility, and then drive a new truckload in the opposite direction, without an opportunity to infect anyone else?
Quarantining between shipments would mean drivers are mostly idle, driving the cost of shipping through the roof. Changing supply contracts so drivers exchange cargo at the border requires completely reworking highly optimized logistics networks and isn’t going to happen in a few years, certainly not by fiat from some bureaucrat or politician that has no experience in logistics.
Can you fill in the details of how exactly it is easier?
> Quarantining between shipments would mean drivers are mostly idle, driving the cost of shipping through the roof.
Well, if they don't need to sleep between shipments, I guess they can drive back directly and get their supplies and food at home. I wasn't suggesting a full two-week quarantine if they don't intend to have any contact with locals anyway, just staying for the night isolated from anyone they could potentially infect.
I didn't do it for me.
It's virtuization of fear and little else.
That sounds like crocodile tears to me. I don't see how going to bars and flying commercial would have made the people working in grocery delivery and amazon safer.
And it would absolutely have put the people in my life who are at the highest risk at an even greater risk if I had done so.
Korea meanwhile applied strict, severe, surgical lockdowns and then were able to fully reopen after containment.
People haven't been able to go see their families out of the country. I've not been able to practice my sport (figure skating) since October (they even banned it outdoors during winter!!). And there is a pages-long, ever-changing document on social bubbles, checklists on who you can see which take things such as age and household size into account, etc. It's dumb, people don't follow it, and it has deeply eroded trust in institutions, and it has pushed people into antivax groups because those are the most vocal ones against measures like these (so they are the sole ones sounding like the voice of reason).
The "alternative" to the above is not brazil, and I would personally much rather be in Korea.
And these measures, while on paper sound like they're slowing the spread, are also pushing people to be against government measures as a whole and feed into much more dangerous sentiments. Would you apply a measure that reduces the spread by 0.1% if it also meant a 0.1% decrease in mask usage? Or a 0.25% decrease in vaccine uptake? What if you can't know any of those numbers, you just know they exist?
----
Edit: Just to really drive home my point: I've been advocating for this for months. Just as I posted this comment, the following article shows up on the Brussels Times: "Belgium needs a short ‘real’ lockdown, warns expert"
https://www.brusselstimes.com/news/belgium-all-news/161157/b...
There is no strategy, no planning, no logic involved.
If you have a way to halve new infections in x weeks, you can wait for y weeks during which infections double, then apply your countermeasures and after x+y weeks you're back where you started.
Or you could start implementing countermeasures immediately, ease up after x weeks, and after y weeks of growth you're also back where you started.
The only difference between the scenarios is the ordering, but the first leads to a mountain of infections and the second to a valley, i.e. lower total case count and fewer deaths. (Also a chance of extinction if the expected number of infected falls below 1.)
So anything you're willing to do when 100 of 100k are infected is just as good when it's 50 of 100k or really any number greater than zero.
I'm in Taiwan (and was for SARS in 2003). We had early travel restrictions and have to quarantine for 14-days after returning from abroad, and have to wear a mask on the subway.
For the past few months there's been a mask rule at some indoor venues but it still allows for restaurants and bars to stay open and maskless. There was a marathon a few months ago with tens of thousands of people.
There hasn't been a lockdown here. Businesses haven't been wrecked. The economy is great. What was so "far and beyond what Americans were willing to tolerate"?
Edit: serious question here! I know there's quite a bit of ignorance about Taiwan internationally, but the rules truly have not been onerous at all. It's gone well because of travel restrictions and an, IMO, justified trust in civic institutions.
I found that people in the West, often simply don't believe me when I tell them that Taiwan didn't lock down at all, and had hardly any Covid deaths. Reactions I have come across have been: "yeah but Taiwan is a dictatorship" and "They are lying about numbers ..." The amount of ignorance is astonishing.
I think it's a psychological problem: most people are perfectly happy to believe that their home countries have somewhat flawed political systems, but find it near impossible to accept that they are orders of magnitude worse than some others.
https://qz.com/1825997/taiwan-phone-tracking-system-monitors...
‘They both pointed out that while there’s broad public support for the digital surveillance, many people don’t fully understand how the technology works. “The main worry is not knowing what it is, not knowing that turning my phone off means the police will come knocking, not knowing how they’re triangulating my coordinates,” Hsieh said, adding that the onus should be on the government to explain the technology clearly.
The government has said the tracking system would be discontinued after the pandemic passes.’
All of these things:
> We had early travel restrictions and have to quarantine for 14-days after returning from abroad, and have to wear a mask on the subway.
There have been multiple people shot for the audacity of asking customers to weak masks.
We have known since early summer of last year that being fat or being old are your two biggest risk factors. Beyond that, if you have some serious pre-existing condition that makes you susceptible to all illnesses.
The messaging should have been "Stay home if you are a high risk group. Otherwise live your live." All current data shows areas that have taken that approach are significantly better off today than the places that hid in a hole the past year.
We have let people treat this like it's an end of the world scenario and it's been good for no one.