Re:Calling for public input on our approach to world leaders
by danaliv on Friday March 19, 2021 @11:32AM
(#26514494)
How about we all admit that this is a simplistic position that flies in the face of centuries of case law trying to work out exactly what "free speech" means and how it squares with people's other fundamental, inalienable rights, because in real life it's not, in fact, obvious?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Calling for public input on our approach to world leaders
by kbelder on Friday March 19, 2021 @02:14PM
(#26516633)
Simple doesn't mean simplistic.
I'd like a platform that removes illegal speech, nothing else. Such a platform should be legal.
Re:Calling for public input on our approach to world leaders
by vulcan01 on Friday March 19, 2021 @11:09PM
(#26520506)
> > centuries of case law trying to work out exactly what "free speech" means and how it squares with people's other fundamental, inalienable rights, because in real life it's not, in fact, obvious?
> platform that removes illegal speech
What constitutes "illegal speech" vs "legal speech"? Clearly, freedom of speech does not give you the right to illegal speech. This is what centuries of case law and legislation have attempted to resolve - what is illegal vs what is not.
EDIT: Heck, all law is like this. I could say "I want murder to be prevented, nothing else" but what if someone kills someone else in self-defence? When is that self-defence?
There are no clear answers.