Well, downtown have something going for it if it's valuable. Land that are of low value aren't exactly prime estate.
Also the mall space is including parking lots and the 9 blocks have parking somewhere but not in those 9 blocks.
Why would that in itself be valuable use of lands? Remember, even the roads are a land use choice.
I think it would be an accurate comparison if those 9 blocks were replaced by a mall, but this seems like apples to oranges if the goal is to see which brings in more tax revenue to the community.
I suppose sales tax would be really important too.
??? It depends entirely on the location of the parking lot.
The land value of a downtown parking lot which is the same size as a high-rise building lot next door is going to be similar. Obviously the high-rise is worth more money since there’s a building with leasable space, but the land value of both lots will be very close. A parking lot doesn’t need to remain a parking lot forever, you could borrow money and build a building on it.
It doesn’t factor in the parking lots needed to support the 9 blocks of downtown.
So the level of spatial resolution seems off to make an accurate comparison.
It seems to me the point was “downtown shopping is better for tax base than malls” and shows the tax for those two areas. But my not including the parking needed for downtown those aren’t really comparable areas in that there is additional space needed to support the downtown area.
But the bigger area is comparing downtown to whatever land was turned into a mall since I’m not aware of any malls that were literally used to replace town squares. In the small to middle towns I’m familiar with the mall was built away from the center of town frequently on farmland or similar empty space.
Also the mall space is including parking lots and the 9 blocks have parking somewhere but not in those 9 blocks.