My reason was this: What's the point of absorbing all that information everyday from sites when I'm not investing what I know into doing something. If you want to seriously get your startup off the ground, for me at least, the right thing to do was to quit TechCrunch, quit Mashable, quit Reddit, and severely limit HN, and actually start getting something done. I'm a much happier peaceful and productive person without the "latest news and opinions" being beamed into my head every few minutes. Mark Zuckerberg is wrong, information overload is real, information addiction is even worse, and once you are free of it, you don't ever want to go back.
edit: On one hand the widgets do bring in traffic but the sluggishness of the site might cancel that out.
Usability didn't look great.
But at least they made the page load faster. Techcrunch is horrible because it takes ages to load. They really need to optimize it.