News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Shifting attention to accuracy can reduce misinformation ... by joshuamorton on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @04:10PM (#26496198)
They did not issue a retraction. They issued a correction. The precise language of the call is different, but the core of the reporting is unchanged.

The precise differences are that, what was quoted as "find the fraud" was actually find "dishonesty", and you'll "a national hero" was actually that you have "the most important job in the country right now". This doesn't change the overall story: Trump attempted to reach out to GA election officials and push them to overturn election results.

> But the harm was already done, the misinformation was already used, and the false quote can be seen on page 10 of this:

None of the citations on page 10 reference this reporting or any of the quotes attributed to Trump on this call.

Re:Shifting attention to accuracy can reduce misinformation ... by Natsu on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @08:11PM (#26498381)
Page 10 says this:

"December 23, for instance, President Trump reportedly called one of Georgia’s lead election investigators, urging him to “find the fraud”" and references, among others:

28 Amy Gardner, ‘Find the Fraud’: Trump Pressured a Georgia Elections Investigator in a Separate Call Legal Experts Say Could Amount to Obstruction, Wash. Post (Jan. 9, 2021).

This specific fake quote was used in the WaPo headline, in a charge of obstruction, and in a criminal referral. The call was secretly recorded, then deleted, so the source knew or should have known this was false.

The wording changes the call from implying some vague kind of quid-pro-quo arrangement to overturn an election to making a complaint because he (wrongly) believed he was a victim of fraud. The faked quotes are relevant to the legal charges brought against Trump. Their source had a recording, so there was no excuse for being inaccurate on something this important.

Re:Shifting attention to accuracy can reduce misinformation ... by joshuamorton on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @09:11PM (#26498768)
> Page 10 says this:

Ah, my mistake, was looking at the 10th page of the document, not page 10 of the document (no blame on your part here, I just hate that this is an ambiguity).

> The call was secretly recorded, then deleted, so the source knew or should have known this was false.

This doesn't follow. We don't know how many people were on the call, nor do we know that they all knew the call was recorded. We don't know who WaPo's source was. There are all kinds of possibilities where the person either was a second hand source (e.g. they weren't on the call, but were in the room when someone on the call, aghast, described it), or was recalling from memory having been on the call, but unaware someone recorded it.

> The wording changes the call from implying some vague kind of quid-pro-quo arrangement to overturn an election to making a complaint because he (wrongly) believed he was a victim of fraud.

It does not. Nothing was directly offered in either case. If you believed it was a quid-pro-quo before, you should still believe it. If you didn't before, than the headline doesn't matter.

Just to clarify, here are some things Trump said on the recording.

- “When the right answer comes out, you’ll be praised.” - “whatever you can do, Frances, it would be — it’s a great thing. It’s an important thing for the country. So important. You’ve no idea. So important. And I very much appreciate it.”

If you thought there was a quid pro quo originally, Trump's words, as spoken, still support it. If you're looking for a way to excuse his actions, yes, this gives you a scapegoat. You can blame the WaPo for bad reporting, instead of Trump for committing a crime.

Notably however, WaPo didn't contend that Trump tried to negotiate a quid-pro-quo. They simply reported the facts, as best they could.

> Their source had a recording

This is, again, untrue. There's nothing to suggest that Frances Watson was WaPo's source. There's nothing to suggest that anyone who is not Frances Watson knew there was a recording.

> and in a criminal referral

And in the course of that criminal referral, the actual recording, which, to reiterate, isn't exculpatory, was found. What's your point.

Re:Shifting attention to accuracy can reduce misinformation ... by Natsu on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @11:35PM (#26499471)
This is what I mean by "unringing a bell" though. Due to the initial (false) framing, people end up with trapped priors: https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/trapped-priors-as-a-ba...

In the end, it doesn't matter whether this is accidental or not, people are sharing the most salacious headlines and those are often significantly undercut by the story beneath them even at the time of writing because they get selected for "engagement" and A-B tested or similar.

So circling back to the story we're discussing, the problem goes deeper than just people trying to ensure that they share only the most accurate stories, there are significant problems with the supply even from the most trusted outlets.

Re:Shifting attention to accuracy can reduce misinformation ... by joshuamorton on Thursday March 18, 2021 @01:09AM (#26499844)
I think you're more guilty here than WaPo. You're choosing to frame this as a larger mistake than it was, calling it a "retraction" is both factually wrong (WaPo didn't call it that, they called it a correction), and misleading (the change doesn't affect the article's main point[0]).

I'll reiterate: the framing didn't change. The precise quotes changed, but they don't affect the framing, and WaPo didn't alter the framing. This is consistent with a correction. The article headline, using only quotes that Trump actually said, could still have been "Trump told investigator that 'you'll be praised' for finding that I 'Won by hundreds of thousands of votes'."

That's a headline supported by the both the intent, and the precise words of the actual call.

You're trying to reframe a correction of precise quotes as a retraction, or a completely misleading story on the part of Wapo. But that's you doing that. Like I said, the correction is a great excuse if you already wanted the story to be wrong, but that's entirely on you. Similarly, you're framing of this as a "fake quote", which implies that it was a fabrication, as opposed to, what the evidence points to, an first or possibly second hand account, from memory, further charges a reader of your editorialization. But that's entirely your framing (and your assumptions), not a fact. I can't tell if you're intending to point out your own cognitive bias, but yes, you are showing that you're guilty of holding trapped priors. You're not demonstrating that anyone else is.

[0]: https://www.dmlp.org/legal-guide/correcting-or-retracting-yo....

Re:Shifting attention to accuracy can reduce misinformation ... by Natsu on Friday March 19, 2021 @11:13PM (#26520525)
If they weren't the main point of the article, why was that exact false quote used in the impeachment?
Re:Shifting attention to accuracy can reduce misinformation ... by joshuamorton on Saturday March 20, 2021 @04:13PM (#26525779)
Because that's generally how you reference things.

Do you think the point of the article was

1. Trump said these exact words.

2. Trump attempted to convince GA election officials to sway votes, by suggesting that they'd be rewarded for marking democratic ballots as fraudulent?

If 1, why was this important to people? If 2, how does the precise wording change impact the overall narrative?

Re:Shifting attention to accuracy can reduce misinformation ... by Natsu on Sunday March 21, 2021 @01:33PM (#26532166)
You've changed a fuzzy and incoherent quote about looking for evidence that the vote was tampered with into a clear directive. This is central, or it wouldn't be the thing that everyone uses to reference the event.

And to be clear, I am specifically saying they're wrong about it being a "correction" instead of a retraction as well. They can call it what they like, but when the central quote that they based the narrative on is false, the whole thing collapses.

Re:Shifting attention to accuracy can reduce misinformation ... by joshuamorton on Sunday March 21, 2021 @10:52PM (#26536370)
There is still as much of clear directive in the recording. I'm not sure why you don't believe that.
Re:Shifting attention to accuracy can reduce misinformation ... by Natsu on Monday March 22, 2021 @09:06PM (#26549696)
Trump is seemingly incapable of being clear, as your own quotes of him being incoherent establish:

- “When the right answer comes out, you’ll be praised.” - “whatever you can do, Frances, it would be — it’s a great thing. It’s an important thing for the country. So important. You’ve no idea. So important. And I very much appreciate it.”

Re:Shifting attention to accuracy can reduce misinformation ... by p1necone on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @07:46PM (#26498203)
Not sure why you're being downvoted, the differences from the reporting and the actual call are exactly the sorts of differences you'd expect if their anonymous source was someone who had heard the call once and was conveying the wording based off of memory. There's no significant difference in meaning as far as I can tell - Trump was still instructing them to find him votes.