News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scientists grow mice embryos in a mechanical womb by bpodgursky on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @01:01PM (#26493896)
This is so trite. How do you feel about artificial legs? Hearts?

There are a lot of women who would love to have children, but have PCOS, hysterectomies, or other problems becoming pregnant naturally. Why is it totally OK for me to wear glasses, half the country to have an artificial hip, but totally 100% unnatural and terrible for women to use an artificial womb?

Re:Scientists grow mice embryos in a mechanical womb by Sporktacular on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @01:13PM (#26494086)
It's not if it's developed ethically. The price of this research is often paid by the suffering of countless animals. Aa externality that may be slightly less odious if it is at least there to reduce our suffering, not simply cash in on making more humans.
Re:Scientists grow mice embryos in a mechanical womb by throwaway316943 on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @01:53PM (#26494642)
There’s literally a part of the article that expounds on how this could reduce or eliminate the need to sacrifice mice when studying certain domains.
Re:Scientists grow mice embryos in a mechanical womb by Sporktacular on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @02:28PM (#26495039)
And if its development requires the sacrifice of as many mice as it saves then it only breaks even. Ethically, that case hasn't been made. And what comes out shouldn't suffer.
Re:Scientists grow mice embryos in a mechanical womb by bpodgursky on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @01:22PM (#26494221)
I don't think you understand the human condition (or how to think outside your own life) if you think that infertility doesn't count as suffering.
Re:Scientists grow mice embryos in a mechanical womb by Sporktacular on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @01:31PM (#26494352)
Trying for a kid with my partner actually. It doesn't mean we're entitled to one or that my child will have more of a right to exist than 100s of some other mammals.

And I think it's clear that I am considering more than just my own life.

Re:Scientists grow mice embryos in a mechanical womb by bpodgursky on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @03:05PM (#26495512)
I personally believe your child has more right to exist than 1 mouse, 1,000 mice, or 1,000,000 mice.

People are people. It's a different bar, and I'm not going to equate people lives with animal lives.

Re:Scientists grow mice embryos in a mechanical womb by Sporktacular on Sunday March 21, 2021 @08:13AM (#26529840)
A bar set by people, in the interest of people. What we personally believe is subject to biases, in this case speciesism. A human would say what you say, a monkey's claim to superiority might be branch selection skills. What makes your red line inherently stronger?

And it's not like you defined one or attempt to find a rational underpinning to check for your bias. That's the tribal, conservative basis for many of the injustices over immutable differences we see every day (racial, sexual etc.)

Rational inquiry is about transcending this.