Perhaps there should be legal escape hatches from HOA rules specifically for energy efficiency upgrades. I don't generally advocate for centralization of power (ie, a state imposing its will on a community), but in the case of climate change I'll happily make exceptions.
For example, the FCC has a carve-out that allows you to put up a satellite dish, in spite of any HOA regulation.
However, if a group of people want to make a legally enforceable agreement between themselves for their mutual benefit, then it shouldn't be possible for one of them to renege on that agreement later.
See also: easements (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Easement). You can own property but if an easement exists then you can't do whatever you want with it. If easements were suddenly unenforceable, chaos would ensue. So the matter is certainly not as simple as "if you own something you should be able to do whatever you want with it".
Taking a wider view, HOAs are a form of free association and I can't condemn them entirely. If people want to subject themselves to complete hell, they should be able to. And frankly, the kind of neighborhood that has an HOA is not the place I'd want to live anyway, so it's not like I'm personally missing anything.
That said, the existence of HOAs should not be a driver for climate change, and aesthetics and property values are a really stupid thing to optimize for when we're facing catastrophic climate collapse.
I think an argument against this is that the HOA follows the property, not the consumer. If I could opt out of an HOA when purchasing a home, it wouldn't be so bad. (but then again, the HOA would likely be severely weakened.)
An HOA is effectively just a contractual micro-state, and conversely, some counties are a scaled HOA.
That said, I agree with you. I think HOAs are stupid, at least in the context of telling people what their shrubs should look like or what color to paint their house.
It's a fair argument that conversely many types of restrictions on what you can do are unjustified and overly broad, but arguing from the basis that you should be able to do as you please will fall flat on its face because it is so easy to find examples that would massively negatively affect neighbours.
Well yes, if you practice the tuba at 3am, raise alligators in your backyard, and beekeeping in your front yard, then yes.
But painting your house? Building a shed? Parking a car in the driveway? Building a fence? Adding architectural ornaments? Install solar panels? None of this stuff affects neighbours.
Examples: no cars parked on your front yard.
Check.
No solar panels on your roof.
That would be too far.
This would be too far. If the front yard and car are both my property it is not for anyone else to tell me what to do with them.
E.g. near me planning regulations generally prevent new construction from creating more than an average of 1.5 parking space per housing unit, to prevent further strain on the transport network. One might argue it's a poor proxy, as some people will have cars just sitting around, but it tends to work reasonably well.
There certainly is over-reach, and one of my pet peeve is that restrictions like this (and ideally all regulations and laws) ought to have stated justifications as part of the text, and "test conditions" to validate if they achieve the goal, as it's often hard to unpackage why the rules are the way they are, but a lot of these restrictions do have a reasoning behind them as well. Whether or not one agree about that reasoning is a separate issue, but I think a lot of conflict over these kinds of regulations boils down to not knowing the reasoning behind them.
I had a friend who lived in a dome house. It could not have been built in an incorporated area of his state.
If I own the land, I fucking own it, and I solely decide what is done with it. The HOAs do not own it, and they can fuck off. I live in the land of the free, and I'll build my dome. Mandatory HOAs should be outlawed.
Where you get into trouble is when they also try to enforce "property value" guidelines, which tend to become "against whatever the most power tripping person on the council thinks is 'ugly'". Solar panels are exactly the sort of thing that can be considered "ugly" and end up being banned. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder.
All of that stuff can exist without HOAs. If you want access to communal property and a communal parking sticker, you can require a membership fee. As long as it's reasonably priced I'd most likely gladly pay for access to parks and communal facilities and stuff like that. It should be optional, but for the above, I'd be likely to opt in and I'm sure most people would.
But no, I would not pay for them to come and yak at me for how I should decorate my front yard and house.
None of that stuff affects maintainence. Those farts shouldn't even be allowed to step on land they don't own.
The stuff that actually affects maintainence, I can understand, but participation should be optional by law. If you want discount maintainence, don't mess with your water pipes and electrical conduits. But hey if you're okay with finding your own maintainence, you should be entitled to do whatever you want as long as it's legal per fire/building code.
HOAs don't make a lick of sense for suburban blocks, but you can't do without them when you share a building.
[1] You could try the Soviet model, where people took care of their personal apartments, while the common areas and infrastructure of most buildings would go to shit. I've seen it, I'm not eager to re-live it.
I was referring more to HOAs for suburban blocks, which are extraordinarily common in the US. Many of them are obsessed about whether you can park your car in the driveway, what kind of car you're allowed to own, what kinds of plants you can plant in your front yard, the color of your house, modifications to the aesthetics of your house, and other stupid things. Welcome to the "land of the free".
It's maintained by an organization that is the exact same thing as an HOA, but is called a strata.
HOAs wouldn't be so bad if rules were grandfathered-in when you bought your house.
It's not your property. Stay out.
To be literal, the reason I think "I" (actually the HOA) have a say is because a bunch of legal paperwork says so. All the home owners signed it.
A year from now I won't have any say, because I won't be on the board.
Generally, I like the HOA since they mow my lawn. But if you are religiously opposed to being a member of an HOA, then you just wouldn't move into a house that's subject to one. All the people that live in this neighborhood were aware of it before they moved in.
Different people want different things.
They were forced to sign it if they wanted to purchase property. If it was optional I wouldn't be angry. To me the entire reason for owning instead of renting would be to be able to modify the hell out of it to my house of my dreams. Yes I could avoid moving into an HOA neighborhood, but HOAs are spreading like viruses and it's becoming increasingly difficult to find a place that doesn't have one.
I would just ask that the law make HOAs optional when purchasing property. If you want the benefits HOAs give you (if any), you're welcome to join, but you shouldn't be forced to join one just because you want to move into a certain district.
> A year from now I won't have any say, because I won't be on the board.
So now the house you supposedly "own" will be governed by some people that you don't even know. If they don't like your yellow car they could make a fit of it. I'm angry because if I owned property in a free country they shouldn't even be legally allowed to make a fit of something that isn't impinging on their freedom.
> Generally, I like the HOA since they mow my lawn.
I'd rather save the HOA fees and pay for a lawnmowing service.
> So now the house you supposedly "own" will be governed by some people that you don't even know.
"Governed?" I wouldn't really say that. I'm still allowed to take a shit whenever I want, and use as much toilet paper as I feel is right and proper.
If you want to argue about the existence of HOAs, I'm probably not the best counterparty. I don't feel too strongly one way or another. Just giving my perspective on whether HOAs would "lose their shit" over solar panels.
I don't deny you from your right to live in an HOA neighborhood, but I strongly oppose the HOA making it a requirement that you join them. It should be optional, and you can join if you want.
The existence of a (mandatory) HOA seems to increase property value. I have no economics training, but this seems to be a signal from the invisible hand that they are generally desirable in those cases.
The only ways they're likely to go away is if they're regulated out of existence, or they fall out of favor in a way that's reflected in property value.
To my neighbors who don't like solar panels because they "decrease property values" (the favorite bugaboo of HOAs), I reply that in 10 years any house that does not have solar panels will be perceived as deficient, especially in the southwestern US.