Re:Google Took Down My Chrome Extension for Using Lodash
by ajross on Monday March 15, 2021 @09:00PM
(#26471607)
Yeah, pretty much. Extensions shouldn't be obfuscated. Would you choose to run code in a privileged context (and "the whole browser" is awfully privileged!) if you suspected the author was hiding something? Same principle.
In this case, the review was pretty much correct. The code absolutely looked obfuscated, forcing the author to dig through a bunch of dependencies just to figure out where the offending strings (in HIS OWN EXTENSION!) were coming from.
And the answer turned out to be benign. But it sure didn't look benign until a relatively deep analysis was done. Extension reviews aren't supposed to be for deep analysis.
In this case, the review was pretty much correct. The code absolutely looked obfuscated, forcing the author to dig through a bunch of dependencies just to figure out where the offending strings (in HIS OWN EXTENSION!) were coming from.
And the answer turned out to be benign. But it sure didn't look benign until a relatively deep analysis was done. Extension reviews aren't supposed to be for deep analysis.