I find that I still have energy to think about programming when I get home from work - that's why I'm on Hacker News or Proggit. I just don't have energy to actually program. Those are two different skills, and it seems actually programming draws from the same pool of energy as keeping customer's orders straight, not from the pool of talking about programming.
It can be done, but it's very stressful, both because you're pretty much spending all your waking hours either working or "at work", plus you usually have actual responsibilities at your day job that you're trying to get done while already tired.
I think that a lot of people confuse "value to the firm" with "intrinsic value"
It's actually a pretty old idea. The world is full of aspiring actors waiting tables, aspiring writers working at Starbucks, etc.
>> full of aspiring actors waiting tables, aspiring writers
I perceived the argument differently. A closer analogy might be that if you want to make it big as a screen writer, you should do something besides writing during the day, so you have the mental energy to write your screenplay at night.(not arguing the same point myself - if you want to become a great writer, you should be writing all the time. This might make sense if you have already developed your writing skills sufficiently).
#2 is more of a stretch - you need other skills to start your own business and capitalize on your strengths (edit: the reason many of us follow this site).
#3 is an interesting idea that I haven't seen expressed elsewhere.