News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Life of an Implementer: If you're good at it, don't do it... by dctoedt on Saturday June 11, 2011 @07:57PM (#2645214)
Which leg of the stool is most important?
Re:Life of an Implementer: If you're good at it, don't do it... by crasshopper on Saturday June 11, 2011 @08:25PM (#2645259)
Why does this egotistical viewpoint keep coming up on HN frontpage? Do most programmers think they're the only important member of a team?

Is everyone frothing to themselves at their desks, muttering that they could do better on their own and should quit to start their own business?

Re:Life of an Implementer: If you're good at it, don't do it... by potatolicious on Saturday June 11, 2011 @09:15PM (#2645362)
I'm with you - I'm pretty tired of hearing the tired arguments about how developers are the lynchpin in every single thing that's even remotely related to technology.

Programmers have some of the biggest egos I've ever seen out of any profession. We give Wall Street bankers a run for their money when it comes to how self-absorbed and how self-aggrandizing we are.

So very sick and tired of coders belittling the role of everyone else in this society - 95% of coders out there wouldn't even remotely be able to cut it on their own without the umbilical of a stable, sizable employer. There are a lot more skills one needs to survive in their own business than simply the ability to implement software.

Re:Life of an Implementer: If you're good at it, don't do it... by mattdeboard on Saturday June 11, 2011 @11:28PM (#2645565)
You'd be very hard-pressed to find a profession-specific forum of any kind that's not full of participants who think their profession is more important than others in their organization.

I switched to software development in my 30s, after a career in PR and marketing. Talented software developers ARE some of the most impressive professionals I've ever met. And frankly, many many many marketeer and PR people deserve the ridicule. Heck, maybe even 95% :)

Re:Life of an Implementer: If you're good at it, don't do it... by crasshopper on Sunday June 12, 2011 @01:05AM (#2645704)
The quants on Wilmott & NuclearPhynance don't seem to think they're the linchpin. Maybe traders taunt them so much they know their place.
Re:Life of an Implementer: If you're good at it, don't do it... by bastiat on Sunday June 12, 2011 @06:02AM (#2646208)
We let them think we know our place. After all they are the implementers... I guess. Which mostly goes to show how malleable that line is.
Re:Life of an Implementer: If you're good at it, don't do it... by drsnyder on Saturday June 11, 2011 @11:24PM (#2645557)
From my experience (as a programmer) I have seen what I would consider both mediocre and talented developers who fit your description of frothing to themselves thinking they could do better on their own. Neither performed up to their abilities mainly because of the distraction that the frothing caused.

I the case of one talented developer, I was tempted to ask them the following question but held back: What makes you think you could do this kind of work at a high level as an entrepreneur when you are struggling doing it for someone else?

Re:Life of an Implementer: If you're good at it, don't do it... by gphil on Saturday June 11, 2011 @09:11PM (#2645354)
Not sure why you got down-voted for this, maybe you touched a nerve. I up-voted you for having a realistic perspective. Obviously (good) programmers are some of the most valuable employees around--but what about sales, support, etc? One can't be successful on their own just by coding. At a minimum one has to also sell, document and support software for it to really create value.
Re:Life of an Implementer: If you're good at it, don't do it... by crasshopper on Sunday June 12, 2011 @01:23AM (#2645740)
Maybe because it sounded like I was disagreeing with dctoedt, who is obviously right. See Poeisis' comment below.
Re:Life of an Implementer: If you're good at it, don't do it... by xiaoma on Monday June 13, 2011 @10:36AM (#2649142)
People who can sell are also critical, but the difference is that salespeople's performance is more easily quantifiable than most others' and the stars generally do take in outsized earnings via commissions and/or bonuses. It's also easier for their mediocre colleagues to take, when they know that the money the they make is tied directly to how much they're bringing in for the company.
Re:Life of an Implementer: If you're good at it, don't do it... by mcantelon on Saturday June 11, 2011 @09:28PM (#2645380)
Some developers spend each day having questionable ideas pushed at them by people who have acquired organizational power through politics rather than technical/strategic knowledge. These developers should either strike out on their own, find new jobs, push back in the organization.
Re:Life of an Implementer: If you're good at it, don't do it... by damoncali on Saturday June 11, 2011 @10:21PM (#2645471)
Supply and demand. In '98-'99 kids got big heads because they knew HTML. It will sort itself out in a year or two.
Re:Life of an Implementer: If you're good at it, don't do it... by Poiesis on Saturday June 11, 2011 @11:05PM (#2645528)
How is it that the analogy of a stool--which generally needs three legs, minimum--is interpreted as a programmer's egotistical viewpoint?
Re:Life of an Implementer: If you're good at it, don't do it... by crasshopper on Sunday June 12, 2011 @01:10AM (#2645719)
Oops, I didn't mean it to sound that way. I agree with dctoedt. Only an egotist couldn't see dctoedt's point.