Re:Is a long-dismissed forgery the oldest known Biblical man...
by R0b0t1 on Saturday March 13, 2021 @05:14PM
(#26450552)
I have also seen it construed the original prohibition was against pedastery as practiced by the Greeks, not homosexuality in general.
Re:Is a long-dismissed forgery the oldest known Biblical man...
by andrewflnr on Saturday March 13, 2021 @09:18PM
(#26452177)
Pretty sure that pertains to the New Testament (e.g. Paul), not the Pentateuch. I don't know the exact timeline, but I don't think the ancient Greeks as we know them were a factor when the Old Testament law was written.
Re:Is a long-dismissed forgery the oldest known Biblical man...
by InfiniteRand on Sunday March 14, 2021 @12:23AM
(#26453018)
There’s some decent evidence that the Philistines were Greek, although they would have been Greeks before the period when Greeks wrote much about pedastery so your point probably is still valid
Re:Is a long-dismissed forgery the oldest known Biblical man...
by R0b0t1 on Monday March 15, 2021 @11:10AM
(#26466917)
I think pederasty was relatively common, I didn't mean to associate it just with Greek influence.
Re:Is a long-dismissed forgery the oldest known Biblical man...
by andrewflnr on Sunday March 14, 2021 @11:01AM
(#26455961)
Ah, that's fascinating. TIL.
Re:Is a long-dismissed forgery the oldest known Biblical man...
by thaumasiotes on Saturday March 13, 2021 @07:19PM
(#26451517)
> Dershowitz suggests that an earlier version of Leviticus 18 forbade homosexual incest, which if true would in turn lead to the conclusion that homosexuality wasn't forbidden in general.
That's fine as far as it goes, but it seems unlikely that there would be a specific prohibition on homosexual incest as opposed to incest in general.
Re:Is a long-dismissed forgery the oldest known Biblical man...
by lucas_membrane on Sunday March 14, 2021 @12:47AM
(#26453096)
Why? In more recent times in America, the New Amsterdam colony prohibited adulterous sex with heathens.
Re:Is a long-dismissed forgery the oldest known Biblical man...
by rsynnott on Saturday March 13, 2021 @08:32PM
(#26451925)
So, Leviticus doesn't just say "no incest, please"; it has quite a long list of forbidden combinations. 18:7 and 18:14 refer to both male-male and male-female incest but are weirdly worded; Dershowitz's contention is that after the putative addition of 18:22 (the "no sex with men" one) they were reworded to de-emphasise the male part (as, if there's a general prohibition on male-male sex, they'd seem a bit superfluous.)
If you follow the link to the 2018 "startling claim" (https://archive.is/QAa5x), what's presented there is not a claim of "explicit permission" as you say, but a reasoning from the principle that "For example, a sign declaring an office to be closed on Sundays suggests that the office is open on all other days of the week". (That is, in that article Idan Dershowitz suggests that an earlier version of Leviticus 18 forbade homosexual incest, which if true would in turn lead to the conclusion that homosexuality wasn't forbidden in general.)