News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Connecticut Killed Affiliate Marketing with Amazon.com by jbooth on Saturday June 11, 2011 @04:53PM (#2644835)
Thanks, that's the argument exactly, specifically the second part.

Regarding the static model, it's not so much that it's a static model as that for the overwhelming majority of online purchases, it's displacing a local purchase. It's actually a more capitalist economy from a certain point of view to make online and local purchasing compete on the same ground, especially when the market distortion (which yes stems from sales taxes' existence in the first place, coupled with the commerce clause) discriminates against your voters.

Re:Connecticut Killed Affiliate Marketing with Amazon.com by yummyfajitas on Saturday June 11, 2011 @11:27PM (#2645564)
Online and local purchasing do compete on the same ground. A local store uses CT state services and pays taxes to support them. An online store does not use CT state services and does not pay taxes to support them.

Similarly, many companies use Microsoft software and pay license fees. My company does not.

Would it be "more capitalist" if we were forced to pay a Microsoft tax, to eliminate the "market distortion" of using lower cost software?

Re:Connecticut Killed Affiliate Marketing with Amazon.com by crasshopper on Sunday June 12, 2011 @01:20AM (#2645733)
yummyfajitas, I think by "more capitalist" jbooth means "more competitive". You are obviously right that forcing companies to use higher-cost inputs is inefficient, but taxes are not an input -- they're a necessary burden meant to be shared.

To take an extreme example, using a tax shelter could lower the cost of a company's services while decreasing the efficiency of the economy.

Re:Connecticut Killed Affiliate Marketing with Amazon.com by yummyfajitas on Sunday June 12, 2011 @01:46AM (#2645775)
Of course taxes pay for inputs - the inputs are public goods. Taxes are compulsory only to prevent freeloading - you might enjoy the benefits of the CT state police without paying for them.

Amazon doesn't enjoy the benefit of the CT state police. Hence, it is not efficient to force them to pay for it.

A tax shelter is only inefficient if it allows a company to consume services while forcing others to pay for them. If a company does not consume those services, it is inefficient to force the company to pay for them.

Re:Connecticut Killed Affiliate Marketing with Amazon.com by crasshopper on Sunday June 12, 2011 @02:11AM (#2645809)
yummyfajitas, can you give a real-world example of a tax haven which is Pareto equivalent or superior to the company paying its taxes?

Also, who says Amazon pays the tax? Insert elasticity argument.

Re:Connecticut Killed Affiliate Marketing with Amazon.com by yummyfajitas on Sunday June 12, 2011 @03:19AM (#2645948)
In the real world nothing is Pareto equivalent or superior to anything else, except maybe for gifts given to hermits. Pareto efficiency is a purely theoretical construct.
Re:Connecticut Killed Affiliate Marketing with Amazon.com by crasshopper on Sunday June 12, 2011 @03:46AM (#2645995)
You're dodging the essence of the question. Give us one real world example of a case where tax evasion has been A Good Thing.

yummyfajitas, it frankly sounds like you're econtrolling. I looked at your profile and you seem like a smart, educated person, so I'll respond in good faith so you can see how weak your arguments sound.

> Taxes are compulsory only to prevent freeloading

Says who? This sounds like a stylised model from Econ 101.

> A tax shelter is only inefficient if it allows a company to consume services while forcing others to pay for them.

Prove it.

> Amazon doesn't enjoy the benefit of the CT state police.

I don't use the Merritt Parkway but that doesn't mean I don't owe tax on it.

> Pareto efficiency is a purely theoretical construct.

This from someone who just boiled the entire political economy of Connecticut down to a prisoner's dilemma?

> If a company does not consume those services, it is inefficient to force the company to pay for them.

What is your reasoning?

Perhaps you are sharing these thoughts before giving them a sound-check? I don't mean to be rude but what you're saying doesn't make sense coming from someone of your educational background.

Re:Connecticut Killed Affiliate Marketing with Amazon.com by yummyfajitas on Sunday June 12, 2011 @04:49AM (#2646096)
First of all, you are conflating tax avoidance (taking actions to avoid tax liability) with tax evasion (lying to the tax authorities about your liabilities).

In the real world, one efficient "tax shelter" is Amazon locating itself outside of CT. If Amazon were to pay taxes to CT, then CT would produce the public services necessary to support Amazon. Since Amazon is not located in CT, this would be wasteful. Thus, Amazon locating themselves outside of CT and avoiding CT taxes is A Good Thing.

[edit: you appear to have edited your post extensively after I responded to it. It's generally polite to indicate when you do this.]

Re:Connecticut Killed Affiliate Marketing with Amazon.com by crasshopper on Sunday June 12, 2011 @05:22AM (#2646139)
> you are conflating tax avoidance with tax evasion

Fair enough. I meant to use tax evasion as an extreme example to prove the inner case, but I can see how it would look like conflation.

> one efficient "tax shelter" is Amazon locating itself outside of CT

Petitio principii.

> Since Amazon is not located in CT, this would be wasteful.

Does not follow. Where is the dead weight loss?

Re:Connecticut Killed Affiliate Marketing with Amazon.com by SamReidHughes on Sunday June 12, 2011 @04:17AM (#2646037)
Literally every case of tax evasion under a government where the tax rate is too high and the marginal utility of higher taxes is negative.
Re:Connecticut Killed Affiliate Marketing with Amazon.com by crasshopper on Sunday June 12, 2011 @04:25AM (#2646054)
Can you give a real example of a case where this has actually happened? (by marginal utility I assume you mean marginal revenue; governments do not have utility)
Re:Connecticut Killed Affiliate Marketing with Amazon.com by SamReidHughes on Sunday June 12, 2011 @04:35AM (#2646074)
No I mean marginal utility. Governments have utility. For example, they do things like give people money to maintain roads. The marginal utility of higher taxes would be the value of the extra amount of road maintainance, and all other changes to the physical universe, that happens as a result. (Edit: So compare the universes where the government rakes in $x and $x+epsilon of revenue. Which is a better universe? There are plenty of governments where $x+epsilon would produce a worse universe. It might depend on who it gets the extra epsilon from.)
Re:Connecticut Killed Affiliate Marketing with Amazon.com by crasshopper on Sunday June 12, 2011 @04:43AM (#2646082)
Utility is only defined for individuals. It sounds like you're trying to talk about how some sum of citizens' utility functions changes as a result of a change in government spending.

Response to your edit: you haven't defined "better". And I'm still waiting for a real world case where $x+$epsilon has been dominated by $x.

Re:Connecticut Killed Affiliate Marketing with Amazon.com by SamReidHughes on Sunday June 12, 2011 @04:46AM (#2646091)
Yes, that's what I'm talking about.

So wait, you're looking for a case where $x+$epsilon government revenue has greater utility than $x?

Because that's the opposite of what you were asking for before...

Re:Connecticut Killed Affiliate Marketing with Amazon.com by crasshopper on Sunday June 12, 2011 @04:57AM (#2646114)
First you have to define what "better" means since there are O(300 million) utility functions in the U.S.A.

Second, I want a real-world example of a "negative marginal utility" of taxation -- which tax rate was raised, who it affected, how they evaded it, and why it was good for the society at large.

Re:Connecticut Killed Affiliate Marketing with Amazon.com by SamReidHughes on Sunday June 12, 2011 @05:10AM (#2646129)
Homeless people paying sales taxes.

Do have any other questions?

Re:Connecticut Killed Affiliate Marketing with Amazon.com by crasshopper on Sunday June 12, 2011 @05:24AM (#2646144)
This response does not answer either question.
Re:Connecticut Killed Affiliate Marketing with Amazon.com by SamReidHughes on Sunday June 12, 2011 @05:26AM (#2646151)
I'm sure if you're dissatisfied to my answers then you'd have no problem coming up with some of your own examples.

Edit: Wait, you want me to define a utility function for people? That was your first question? That's just a stupid question. Define your own utility function. I don't care what it is. And your second question is stupid too. Sorry, I'm not a keeper-tracker of tax evasion. So let's say "any time a poor person evades taxes." Or many of those cases. If you want a specific example, too bad. If the lack of a specific counterexample of the kind you specified is actually the barrier preventing you from changing your opinion about this, then you shouldn't bother trying to have opinions about things. The fact that some people get more value in government services than they pay in taxes is proof that there are people whose tax evasion would benefit society at large. This is a simple mathematical truism.

Re:Connecticut Killed Affiliate Marketing with Amazon.com by crasshopper on Sunday June 12, 2011 @06:02AM (#2646209)
> I'm sure if you're dissatisfied to my answers then you'd have no problem coming up with some of your own examples.

I was challenging you on this point because I don't believe you can come up with an actual example of a company's tax evasion benefiting society.

> Wait, you want me to define a utility function for people?

No, I wanted to prompt you to think about defining a single utility function for 300 million people. There is no way to do it, because you cannot compare interpersonal utilities. Your statements about governments having utility suggests that your thinking on this topic is muddled.

> If you want a specific example, too bad.

No empirical evidence, then?

> The fact that some people get more value in government services than they pay in taxes is proof that there are people whose tax evasion would benefit society at large.

It would not benefit society at large; the benefits would be private to the evader and everyone else's tax bill would go up.

> This is a simple mathematical truism.

Not only is it false, but I don't think you know what a truism is. A truism is a tautology.

> stupid ... stupid ... you shouldn't bother trying to have opinions about things

SamReidHughes, there is a saying that to know a little economics is worse than to know none at all. I think you are overconfident in your theories and should be more humble and polite in dialogue with others.

Re:Connecticut Killed Affiliate Marketing with Amazon.com by jwhite on Saturday June 11, 2011 @10:39PM (#2645501)
It may be displacing a local purchase... in a third, unrelated state. Only the affiliate lives in Connecticut, the purchaser may live in Colorado... or Czech Republic, for that matter. I think you have the argument about capitalism backwards. Any time someone says "that's unfair, we should change the laws to help (inefficient business X) compete more effectively with (efficient business Y)", they are directly contradicting the idea of capitalism.

Where the social good lies is sometimes hard to work out; but I'd guess in this case Connecticut residents would be better off with an efficient Amazon and the ability to become Amazon Affiliates than with the small amount of tax revenue that this legislation tries to capture.

Re:Connecticut Killed Affiliate Marketing with Amazon.com by temphn on Sunday June 12, 2011 @03:45AM (#2645992)
Hmmm. "More capitalist" would be to eliminate local sales tax to allow businesses to compete.