However, the article leads by saying "rkyv is similar to Cap'n Proto and FlatBuffers", and then lists some "different design choices that make it stand out", but does not mention here the lack of schema evolution. Since schema evolution is usually considered a critical feature in any of these systems, it really ought to have been mentioned here. It also explains why rkyv is faster -- supporting schema evolution has overhead.
I think this could have been a really cool article if it were phrased as: "Here are the performance benefits that can be achieved in use cases where you can trade off schema evolution." That's legitimately an interesting area to explore!
(Disclosure: I'm the author of Cap'n Proto.)
As an aside, I updated the benchmarks yesterday and addressed some other responses that mentioned that the three libraries all have different behavior around validation. That's another place where the three libraries all differ in their approaches and it does materially affect the benchmarks. I found out that Cap'n Proto does validate-on-read, which is is a really cool idea that gives it a big edge while accessing complex structured data that rkyv takes a long time to validate. It's got me thinking about how to get the same kind of validation-on-demand functionality!
(Disclosure: I'm the author of rkyv - thanks for Cap'n Proto, it's been a big influence)
This is a pretty unfair way to put it. It's on the main page of the docs, which every developer will see. If you're not familiar with the rust community, you may not be aware of how standard this practice is.
> This is a pretty important thing to call out upfront, especially when comparing against other serialization frameworks where this is considered a table stakes feature
It's a benchmark to measure performance, not an analysis of each of the serialization frameworks. A lot of the benchmarked frameworks don't support schema evolution, it's a really small minority that do.
> users really need to understand that this is the trade off they are making
If a developer reads one article about serialization framework performance and proceeds to use the fastest framework while ignoring every other property of it then that's on them. It's always good to have that sort of information available, but I can't hold everyone's hands while they choose their serialization frameworks.
All that being said, work is already being started on schema evolution capabilities. The plan is for it to be separate from the serialization library for better composability and broader applicability.