News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:War on Urchin by benologist on Saturday June 11, 2011 @12:25AM (#2643204)
Pretty sure SEO is the real reason long urls are such a problem, it's why URLs are long and it's why they're all tagged to hell.

There was a time where your site would be

site.com/product.php?id=x or

site.com/product.asp?id=x,

now it's:

site.com/keyword-keyword/keyword/keyword/product-name?urchin or google analytics crud

Re:War on Urchin by hammerdr on Saturday June 11, 2011 @01:02AM (#2643252)
For a short time there, it was:

site.com/dashboard/alerts

We should get back to that. There need to be better ways to do SEO than polluting URLs. Slapping this information on a URL is a misuse of the purpose of URLs (permanent locators for a resource on the web. E.g. even if the resource has moved, there is a response code and a way of reaching the new location).

Re:War on Urchin by SoftwareMaven on Saturday June 11, 2011 @01:19AM (#2643272)
There is a middle-ground, which is good and wholesome. site.com/category/page-name.html gives good context for users (those few of us who understand URLs, anyway ;) that site.com/index.php?id=x doesn't without bloating things for SEO purposes.
Re:War on Urchin by andybak on Saturday June 11, 2011 @04:20AM (#2643467)
Except of course - you wouldn't really need .html (.php or .anything) on a url...
Re:War on Urchin by sbierwagen on Saturday June 11, 2011 @06:19AM (#2643588)
Re:War on Urchin by rmc on Saturday June 11, 2011 @06:51AM (#2643622)
Those sort of URLs are good for discovery aswell. It's easy to navigate and guess other URLs with that.
Re:War on Urchin by jarod on Saturday June 11, 2011 @03:11AM (#2643390)
URLs are long and tagged with parameters for SEM purposes, not SEO. Long URLs that are spidered by Google are usually considered bad from an SEO perspective because they're not "pretty" URLs. There's a lot of incorrect information being passed around on this thread.

All the parameters you see specify campaign variables to help marketers track their campaigns. As for privacy, these parameters don't reveal user behavior on a site. It's only when it's connected to Google Analytics that is placed ON the site that the campaign data is then connected to site data. Long URLs have no adverse affect on the user browsing experience and URL shorteners do a great job of hiding them so removing those parameters simply serves to screw over marketing people that have spent time and money crafting their campaigns and gathering valuable data.

In regards to making it harder to detect duplicate URLs...really??? It's that hard to strip our everything before parameters?

Re:War on Urchin by Lozzer on Saturday June 11, 2011 @08:00AM (#2643691)
No, because you would reasonably requests with different parameters to return different pages.