News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Major discovery' from MIT primed to unleash solar revolu... by ars on Friday August 01, 2008 @01:02PM (#264201)
Thanks for the clarifications.

>artificial photosynthesis" focuses not on carbon fixation but on the transformation of light to electrochemical energy (via electron/proton transfer).

Then why call it photosynthesis? It's not, it's photovoltaics. If you want photosynthesis you have have to fix carbon, or you're making a mockery of the term. And if you are making hydrogen directly, then call it photolysing.

Either way you are not synthesizing anything.

I didn't realize that chlorine is preferred to O2, but what does it matter? I don't want O2, I want H2, and once all the chlorine is gone, won't the sodium hydroxide work just as well as NaCl? Or is that what you mean by 'very basic environment'?

They should rewrite that article and omit any mention of solar, just say they invented a new cheaper way to electrolyze water. Applications include storing energy from solar or wind for when the sun isn't shining.

Doesn't the above paragraph make a lot more sense than the parent article?

Re:'Major discovery' from MIT primed to unleash solar revolu... by ztravis on Friday August 01, 2008 @02:28PM (#264289)
To be honest, I don't know why it's called artificial photosynthesis versus photovoltaics - perhaps it is because this research looks to the actual chemical systems involved in photosynthesis as models for man-made systems (as opposed to trying to develop light-converting systems ab initio). In any case, "artificial photosynthesis" is commonly used to refer to research both on hydrolysis via solar energy and carbon fixation into organic compounds, both of which are fundamental to photosynthesis as a whole.

I was wrong about the chlorine production, actually - it only occurs at high concentrations of salt. Otherwise (or with different solutes), you can produce oxygen. Still, I believe that this reaction is not efficient enough to be feasible as an energy source. Overall, you do want the hydrogen, but you also need an oxidant to, for example, run a fuel cell. I think there are hydrogen-chlorine fuel cells, but I imagine it would be easier and more practical to run a hydrogen-oxygen cell instead to avoid using chlorine gas/producing HCl. In any case, it boils down to developing catalysts to improve the rate and efficiency of this electrolysis (by lowering overpotentials).

I agree with you that your paragraph makes a lot more sense than the parent article. It's annoying how these press releases make things seem much more revolutionary than they really are.