1) A block of ice will occupy room that could've been used for more deer meat(I suppose the size wouldn't matter, of course)
2) A temperature sensor would let you know right away if the power failed, instead of finding out after the fact and forcing you to clean out a freezer full of rotting meat
3) The sensor may also act as a silent alarm system. If the temperature changes suddenly then goes back to normal, it's possible that an intruder opened it up looking for money / food / valuables.
I realize that misses the point of the discussion since the professor was going for the easiest possible solution, but we're hackers here :)
Your computer has a setting on whether or not it should turn back on after power loss, build a low cost circuit that does the same(turns off in case of power loss) and you are done.
Actually, ice sublimates
Ice evaporates, but a large block will take quite a while.
I was thinking of some sort of canary that would trip if power turned off, but that would only tell you if the power ever went off, not how long it was off. No sense wasting a fridge full of meat if the power was off for a few seconds.
A clock that requires electricity but displays the time mechanically with a date on it would also suffice, as you could measure the delta between what it displays and what the time really is (accounting for normal inaccuracies).
If the battery has run out, then there has been enough long power outages that the meat is probably spoiled. If the battery hasn't run out, you have a nice log of what happened when.
Not that I think its better than the ice solution, but theres certainly techie options that you could build for $10 or so.
Cover the deer with crushed ice. If it is still covered when you get back, the meat is still good. Even if the power was out for a while and some of the ice melted. (A large freezer filled with meat and ice will stay cold for quite a while. Even if some of the ice melts and refreezes, the temperature stayed freezing.)
Probably just as well, you won't want it with the putrified carcass in it.
(I keep a ziploc baggie of icecubes in my freezer. It lets me know if my food is going to kill me, and I can use it as ice if I run low!)
Assuming you took a truck hunting, get rid of the problem altogether. Stick the meat in the freezer and stick the freezer in your truck and take it home with you where you can not only monitor it personally, but still enjoy the meat whenever you want. The only concerns then are keeping the freezer interior cold enough for the trip back (pretty easy) and the space at your place.
"During the space race back in the 1960's, NASA was faced with a major problem. The astronaut needed a pen that would write in the vacuum of space. NASA went to work. At a cost of $1.5 million they developed the "Astronaut Pen". Some of you may remember. It enjoyed minor success on the commercial market.
The Russians were faced with the same dilemma.
They used a pencil."
The idea is to show outcome-oriented thinking. The desired outcome wasn't to use a pen, but rather, to simply write or record.
Speaking of pedantic, a flight's outcome is not really safety, nor was space flight what the folklore mentions. It was addressing the requirement to write/record in space.
I've read a book from a former astronaut though, that tend to prove there's some truth to the legend; it was about the vacuum cleaner used in Mir. The NASA devised a sophisticated way to clean up the Space Shuttle; the Russians simply used an ordinary vacuum cleaner from the nearest supermarket.
If it only costs a buck to launch a commercial vacuum cleaner into space, I will eat a hat of your choosing.
One person felt long ago(can't find the exact quote) that there was once a world market for maybe five computers, and others thought that lasers and x-rays would be nothing more than a sham.
To put it another way: http://www.smbc-comics.com/index.php?db=comics&id=2088#c...
For that matter it took a long time for computers to have an impact on productivity. For a while people wondered whether personal computers actually made business sense. Now, in the era of mass global computerized communications the advantages are hard to ignore.
You have a cabin in the woods, with electricity and a freezer. You go hunting and bag a deer with much more meat than can be used in one visit, so you freeze it for use on a future visit. But you want to know while you are away if the electricity fails for any length of time so that the meat may have thawed and spoiled.
After the class spent most of a period arguing over remote monitoring systems and temperature sensors and the like, the professor revealed the simple answer. Freeze a block of ice in the freezer and mark its height. If it is shorter when you return, the power was out so some of it melted.