News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IMessage, Skype, Google Voice, and the death of the phone... by corin_ on Friday June 10, 2011 @11:28AM (#2641183)
Terrible article, really awful. It simply isn't factual.

You can't compare a mobile number to email, they aren't even the same type of thing.

My mobile number, I can port it between different service providers, and use it on any device I want. My gmail/hotmail/yahoo account, I can never move away from the company that gave it to me.

  carrier lock-in - your phone number is a set of handcuffs that prevents you from easily jumping ship, and they know it
Not at all. Carriers would make more money if they let me spend money with them on more than one device at once (e.g. through a desktop app), the reason they don't do it is because the amount it would cost to set that up is not (in their opinion) worth the returns it will bring.

And it isn't even a carrier lock-in, I can port my number to another carrier any time I wish. Sure, if I have a contract then I may have to pay to cancel it, but then if I have a contract to pay for an email service for a year then the same applies there - and it's perfectly possible to have a phone number without a contract.

Re:IMessage, Skype, Google Voice, and the death of the phone... by cheez on Friday June 10, 2011 @12:27PM (#2641429)
Your email problem is easily solved. Get your own domain. I did this the first time I had a problem with my email provider and I've never looked back through multiple acquisitions and subsequent degradation in quality. In fact, I just changed to fastmail last month and it was painless.
Re:IMessage, Skype, Google Voice, and the death of the phone... by corin_ on Friday June 10, 2011 @01:02PM (#2641559)
Yeah, and I have my own domain(s), but for the majority of people, they're not tech people, they just want a simple account to use. And even with a free domain, it's still not more flexible than phone numbers, it's as flexible.