News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

A comment on Debian Running on Rust Coreutils. Parent comment

Re:Debian Running on Rust Coreutils by simias on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @08:09AM (#26410828)
Technically it's based on whether the output is a tty or piped/redirected into something, not whether it's run from the shell's prompt or a script.

So for instance if you run a bare `ls` from a script that outputs straight into the terminal you'll get the multi-column "human readable" output. Conversely if you type `ls | cat` in the shell you'll get the single column output.

It can definitely be surprising if you don't know about it but technically it behaves the same in scripts and interactive environments.

[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:Debian Running on Rust Coreutils by burntsushi on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @02:01PM (#26414767)
That's exactly what I meant. I used "interactively" to mean "attached to a tty." Look at what I was responding to:

"for commands to not alter their behavior based on whether they're attached to a terminal or not"

ls is a clear counter-example of that.

I think the behavior is a good thing. I'm pushing back against this notion of what is "best practice" or not. It's more nuanced than "doesn't change its output format."

[ Parent | on HN ]