News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU seeks to supercharge computer chip production by ggm on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @08:14PM (#26406629)
Historically European "grand plan" computing pushes don't work. It's great to try.

Anyone else worked through 5th generation, the Alvey report and the MITI catchup?

What does work is sustained organic investment in fundamental science and an environment which stimulates SME.

Its the transition to world scale which seems to defeat European initiated planning.

Re:EU seeks to supercharge computer chip production by Koliakis on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @08:19PM (#26406661)
Taiwan was quite successful with the policies they implemented to home-grow a semiconductor industry:

https://www.nap.edu/read/10677/chapter/9

The entire chapter is interesting, but it also mentions how TSMC came to be:

> The government came to realize that it did not yet have an industry—only one company. The private sector was still fearful of risk and could not raise enough money to start new firms. Once again the government put up money, this time to start TSMC. And this time it applied a condition: The government’s share would be less than 50 percent. Lacking enough funds from the private sector, the government made an offer to Philips, which put in almost 35 percent of the initial investment; this pushed the private sector’s share above 50 percent, and TSMC was born. Again, the technology and all the people came from ERSO, including about 130 engineers, the 2-micron CMOS developed at ERSO, and its latest 6-inch-wafer fab. TSMC had no product, only the fab technology, which matched well with the idea of a pure-play foundry.

I don't get why Europe is so bad at this kind of thing.

Re:EU seeks to supercharge computer chip production by bassman9000 on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @08:42PM (#26406795)
Because Taiwan is a single, small country, with a single government, and a great incentive to succeed in semiconductors.

The EU is a conglomerate of 20+ hyperbureaucratic states where the incentive is to drag these initiatives for years and billions, get nowhere, and repeat. A lot of people will make a lot of money, regardless the outcome.

Re:EU seeks to supercharge computer chip production by ggm on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @12:38AM (#26408166)
I'd put it slightly differently. Germans won't fund Philips. France wants CI Honeywell Bull, not Olivetti.

If you want to invest, you either back new starts which wind up being a race to host them, or you back collaborative projects which force Bull, Olivetti, ICL, to work together. Sorry, they just never really work. Too much competitive tension.

Taiwan, its kind-of a bit more apparent. The nasty neighbour is just across the straights. You better get your act together.

Re:EU seeks to supercharge computer chip production by TMWNN on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @01:36AM (#26408463)
This is also why there won't ever be a European Silicon Valley. Paris isn't going to support any Europe-wide effort to create one that isn't located in the Hexagon, nor will Berlin support one that isn't somewhere in Germany. London pre-Brexit would not and did not support anything that might take away from Silicon Fen.

While other US states encourage their own tech centers' growth, Floridians and New Yorkers and Texans are all aware of, benefit from, and are proud of Silicon Valley being in the US.

Re:EU seeks to supercharge computer chip production by imtringued on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @04:13AM (#26409355)
This is a pretty good explanation for why most EU initiatives can't work. It's because they have to make everyone happy, which is an unattainable goal.
Re:EU seeks to supercharge computer chip production by estaseuropano on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @12:06AM (#26407984)
Europe has gigantic research funding in this space, and arguably more fundamental research than probably even the US (which often focuses on gettting things to msrket). Problem is that most successful EU companies get bought out by US (and previously also Chinese) companies before they scale enough.
Re:EU seeks to supercharge computer chip production by ggm on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @12:42AM (#26408184)
This. ETH Zurich, and the IBM Zurich relationship comes to mind. And, The various institutes of like nature. People congregate there to do smart stuff, but then fly off to the land of IPO and giant cars.

People forget how much modern tech comes from Eindhoven. It just wound up being made in Asia, it was invented in labs at Philips, in Eindhoven. Or, the amazing tech in the oil industry which stems in part, from the work done for Radar by GEC Plessy Marconi. Radar for bombs and missiles is in the end, easy to repurpose for Geo. And.. North sea oil happened.

Europe makes amazing hugh value widgets like the machines TSMC use to make the chips Europeans buy. The key point here is that Europe is pretty crap at buying and operating these machines themselves. At scale. TO make widgets people want to buy. OUTSOURCE! (and.. all the things which stem from it)

Re:EU seeks to supercharge computer chip production by timthorn on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @08:22PM (#26406683)
Arm can be seen as a direct product of the UK's Computer Literacy Project, and slightly less directly the broad base of games developers in the UK could be considered another output.

The Transputer was less of a success, but left a legacy that I think can be traced through to Graphcore today.

Re:EU seeks to supercharge computer chip production by ggm on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @09:36PM (#26407107)
Arm is indeed the killer success story but like frauenhoffer it pivoted to "licence the ipr" instead of going into world scale fab.

That's the part Europe seems to miss: making endogenous industry in territory

Re:EU seeks to supercharge computer chip production by zeristor on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @09:11PM (#26406963)
Didn’t the collapse of Inmos go on to start an electronics hub in Bristol, a rather nifty unintended consequence.

I suppose if they tried to replicate that sort of pump priming failure they would be thought of wasting money.

Re:EU seeks to supercharge computer chip production by ggm on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @09:37PM (#26407113)
Wolfson up in scotland did design for fpga which booted apple into a different place then apple disintermediated wolfson
Re:EU seeks to supercharge computer chip production by ampdepolymerase on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @09:20PM (#26407013)
ARM was also for a while an Apple subsidiary. They are not a pure European story.
Re:EU seeks to supercharge computer chip production by billyruffian on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @04:05AM (#26409316)
Partnership (well, joint venture) with Acorn, not subsdiary.
Re:EU seeks to supercharge computer chip production by jariel on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @09:56PM (#26407219)
Airbus would not have grown up organically.

At a certain scale, things don't come out of thin air.

There's almost no chance of something like this happening on it's own, although the initiative is probably doomed, it could feasibly work if done right.

I'm doubtful but there is a path that could work.

Re:EU seeks to supercharge computer chip production by ggm on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @12:42AM (#26408188)
Airbus is what Lockheed-Boeing-McDonnel-Douglas wanted to be, in some ways