I'm not saying the indignation isn't understandable—of course it is. But users here need to use the site for its intended purpose, not for things that destroy its intended purpose.
I'm Israeli, and I know a lot of people in this industry. I know many people like me who actively refuse to work on active offensive cyber solutions because of moral reasons.
OTH I see many greedy people working in NSO and the only thing they think about is money. They don't give a damn about positive or negative consequences of the industry they work in.
But "We face extermination therefore we should be able to get rich by selling our (cyber)weapons to despots who in turn use it against their own citizens" doesn't sound like a winning argument.
But let's focus on Israel again, always the safe scapegoat.
They can, and many have made a "living" by moving on to working on normal tech startups.
Nobody needs to make a killing to make a "living".
You don't need to like it, but you probably wouldn't be able to let me know without acknowledging it.
The industry has technological authority, but that doesn't mean it is owed a moral authority.
Just how (I hope) you wouldn't give moral authority to a grooming gang just because they're super efficient in their trafficking techniques.
Seems more like ‘war’ than a ‘war crime’
That is decidedly not what NSO is doing. They run the C&C servers.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_crime
Asssuming they are running C&C servers as you suggest, which international law of war did that break?
Seems your problem is more with mainstream media. You're deflecting from the argument at hand here. Not to mention, the wrongs of the Israeli cybersec industry, like with NSO group, seem much less covered than Xinjiang genocide (to me, but I'm sure there's ways to quantify the coverage differential)
This article doesn't even try to hide the fact that it is focused on Israel as a nation, while several other nations operate in this space.
> Disney got plenty of backlash for that move from the people paying attention
"So much backlash", yet nothing has been done. Mulan is still distributed, and that thank-you note to Chinese authorities who build and maintain massive prison camps is still there.
It's almost like all these "moral concerns" are just thinly-veiled real politics.
Chinese state authorities imprisoned over a million minorities in prison camps, forcibly sterilizing women.
False equivalence much?
> "So much backlash", yet nothing has been done.
I’m not sure that’s a sound argument here, because nothing is ”being done” about any of the actors mentioned, really.
That's the same Disney that takes action against any works in its catalog that have any trace of supposed racism.
So, Disney tirelessly takes action against dubious subtle traces of racism in 60+ year old works, but won't take any action against real racism subjecting millions of people in China, right now. In fact it embraces this current racism.
Why? Because Disney wants the lucrative Chinese market and needs to play nice, cooperate with, and sometimes even praise the CCP which operates these racist prison camps.
So all the moral outrage against racism in the Muppets etc is just meaningless virtue signalling. Everyone is really doing what is in their best interest, but sometimes it is beneficial to dress that up for PR purposes.
Which is my point.
you're making a ridiculous leap from "worked in intelligence for the government" to "starts selling spyware to the worst human rights abusers in the planet". it just looks to me like you're in the camp of "my country can do no wrong".
I'm also British and feel fine openly criticizing my government for selling weapons to the Saudis.
Would think twice before creating tools for others to do this exact thing
https://www.haaretz.com/jewish/.premium-1948-n-y-times-lette...
Despite siding with the Nazis in WW2, Lehi membership was first granted a general amnesty and later an award was named in their honor.
In other situation it would be funny to point direct parallels between above and state of Israel, but this ain't even slightly funny topic. They achieved impressive things, but these kind of actions make them lose any moral points pretty quickly.