News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by dang on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @01:25PM (#26414307)
Please don't take HN threads further into nationalistic flamewar. This one turned out to be hellish all over this thread, and it's not what this site is for. Nothing so repetitive is what this site is for. High-repetition plus high-indignation equals bad-for-HN.

I'm not saying the indignation isn't understandable—of course it is. But users here need to use the site for its intended purpose, not for things that destroy its intended purpose.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by mola on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @01:48PM (#26402191)
That's such a straw man. You don't have to build a huge commercial industry around the tech we make for our intelligence bureaus. The Israeli intelligence has become a way for greedy people to become billionaires at the price of killing democracy.

I'm Israeli, and I know a lot of people in this industry. I know many people like me who actively refuse to work on active offensive cyber solutions because of moral reasons.

OTH I see many greedy people working in NSO and the only thing they think about is money. They don't give a damn about positive or negative consequences of the industry they work in.

Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by smashah on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @01:38PM (#26402019)
You don't know me. And I don't know you.

But "We face extermination therefore we should be able to get rich by selling our (cyber)weapons to despots who in turn use it against their own citizens" doesn't sound like a winning argument.

Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by NeverFade on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @02:00PM (#26402380)
How many cybersurveillance tools are developed and sold by companies in the US, China, Russia, UK, and quite a few other nations?

But let's focus on Israel again, always the safe scapegoat.

Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by smashah on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @02:09PM (#26402537)
Easy one. Nobody should be selling these things to anyone else. Everyone should keep their weapons to themselves. If you are able to make it, well done now you have that upper hand in that arena. Cant make it? Sorry you can't buy it. Making it and have surplus? Sorry can't sell it - do something useful for society with all that brain power.
Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by NeverFade on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @02:13PM (#26402604)
Right, "nobody should", but everyone does. And somehow we're again laser-focused on just the Israelis who do it. I wonder why.
Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by smashah on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @02:24PM (#26402779)
Oh I see where the confusion lies. This article is about the cyberterrorism companies inside the state of Israel, that's why. If you have articles where other countries are doing this (which of course they are) then please tag me and I will gladly condemn them also.
Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by marshmallow_12 on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @01:59PM (#26402365)
If you phrase it like that, then no. how about "We face extermination, therefore we shall train soldiers who will work for us for a while, they will be able to make a living after their service using those skills"
Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by smashah on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @02:07PM (#26402508)
>they will be able to make a living

They can, and many have made a "living" by moving on to working on normal tech startups.

Nobody needs to make a killing to make a "living".

Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by marshmallow_12 on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @02:27PM (#26402831)
The Multibillion dollar global defense industry refutes you.
Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by smashah on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @02:37PM (#26402996)
Not sure about you, but I don't concede any moral authority to "The Multibillion dollar global defense industry" so the refutation is invalid to say the least.
Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by marshmallow_12 on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @02:45PM (#26403124)
I do. warfare breeds innovation via the military industry, jets, computers, internet, radar, advanced etc etc etc etc, All of which were catalyzed by warfare.

You don't need to like it, but you probably wouldn't be able to let me know without acknowledging it.

Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by smashah on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @03:04PM (#26403424)
Wow.

The industry has technological authority, but that doesn't mean it is owed a moral authority.

Just how (I hope) you wouldn't give moral authority to a grooming gang just because they're super efficient in their trafficking techniques.

Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by stefan_ on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @01:55PM (#26402305)
Selling Turkey a WhatsApp 0day and operating the C&C servers for use in a war zone isn't contributing to peace and Israels survival, it's a war crime. NSO employees should probably be jailed the moment they leave the country.
Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by upbeat_general on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @02:15PM (#26402642)
How justifying the actions you mentioned but how is that a war crime?

Seems more like ‘war’ than a ‘war crime’

Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by stefan_ on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @02:22PM (#26402737)
If you are Raytheon and you sell someone a rocket, maybe come to their country and teach their personnel how to fire it, that's fine. When they decide to use it, you are not involved.

That is decidedly not what NSO is doing. They run the C&C servers.

Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by TedDoesntTalk on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @02:29PM (#26402863)
You are entitled to your own definition of what is and what is not a war crime, but the rest of the world is not obligated to agreed with you.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_crime

Asssuming they are running C&C servers as you suggest, which international law of war did that break?

Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by stefan_ on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @02:39PM (#26403040)
They are mercenaries, of course.
[dead]
Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by techfoolery on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @02:18PM (#26402664)
C'mon guy, that's not good faith argument. I have a whole twitter full of folks calling for war crimes against what China's doing; Not to mention, Disney got plenty of backlash for that move from the people paying attention. (Google Disney Xinjiang and it's so ubiquitous I don't feel the need to link myself)

Seems your problem is more with mainstream media. You're deflecting from the argument at hand here. Not to mention, the wrongs of the Israeli cybersec industry, like with NSO group, seem much less covered than Xinjiang genocide (to me, but I'm sure there's ways to quantify the coverage differential)

Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by NeverFade on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @02:24PM (#26402762)
My point is that there's a massive propaganda campaign targeted specifically at Israel. Many Western and non-Western nations are developing these kinds of tools. They are not at all unique to Israel. Yet again and again, we are exposed to publications targeting Israeli companies, specifically.

This article doesn't even try to hide the fact that it is focused on Israel as a nation, while several other nations operate in this space.

> Disney got plenty of backlash for that move from the people paying attention

"So much backlash", yet nothing has been done. Mulan is still distributed, and that thank-you note to Chinese authorities who build and maintain massive prison camps is still there.

It's almost like all these "moral concerns" are just thinly-veiled real politics.

Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by Cederfjard on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @02:41PM (#26403070)
And the Israelis are also still going about their business without real obstruction from Western powers, aren’t they, much like the Chinese?
Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by NeverFade on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @02:55PM (#26403289)
Israeli private company created some surveillance tools, which is not illegal.

Chinese state authorities imprisoned over a million minorities in prison camps, forcibly sterilizing women.

False equivalence much?

Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by Cederfjard on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @02:58PM (#26403343)
I’m staying out of the larger discussion, I was specifically talking about what you said:

> "So much backlash", yet nothing has been done.

I’m not sure that’s a sound argument here, because nothing is ”being done” about any of the actors mentioned, really.

Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by NeverFade on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @03:09PM (#26403489)
Disney could remove that thank-you note from the Mulan credits. It didn't.

That's the same Disney that takes action against any works in its catalog that have any trace of supposed racism.

So, Disney tirelessly takes action against dubious subtle traces of racism in 60+ year old works, but won't take any action against real racism subjecting millions of people in China, right now. In fact it embraces this current racism.

Why? Because Disney wants the lucrative Chinese market and needs to play nice, cooperate with, and sometimes even praise the CCP which operates these racist prison camps.

So all the moral outrage against racism in the Muppets etc is just meaningless virtue signalling. Everyone is really doing what is in their best interest, but sometimes it is beneficial to dress that up for PR purposes.

Which is my point.

Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by Cederfjard on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @04:23PM (#26404457)
Agreed on all of those specifics, sure.
Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by _alxk on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @01:48PM (#26402194)
how does selling spyware to authoritarian regimes to crackdown on opposition and activists have anything to do with their own survival?
[dead]
Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by _alxk on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @03:14PM (#26403553)
first of all, half my family are war refugees from a field that is way more dangerous than Israel has been in the last 20 years, so let's talk.

you're making a ridiculous leap from "worked in intelligence for the government" to "starts selling spyware to the worst human rights abusers in the planet". it just looks to me like you're in the camp of "my country can do no wrong".

I'm also British and feel fine openly criticizing my government for selling weapons to the Saudis.

Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by cblconfederate on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @04:56PM (#26404882)
Selling their systems to totalitarian governments like azerbaijan is wreaking havok and not advancing peace for israelis. with great power comes great responsibility, yet a lot of israelis play the amoral card in my experience
Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by celticninja on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @02:01PM (#26402397)
when you face extermination and terrorism maybe you...

Would think twice before creating tools for others to do this exact thing

Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by Daho0n on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @01:53PM (#26402264)
Sad how different this reads if you look at it as written by a Muslim or Jew. I wish it made no difference.
Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by wizzwizz4 on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @01:54PM (#26402286)
To me, it doesn't. The people in a position to do this kind of thing are not the same people as are facing the oppression.
Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by DSingularity on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @01:57PM (#26402329)
I wonder, would Israel face the violent opposition it faces today if Israel wasn’t founded through the terrorization of, extermination of, and colonization of the indigenous Palestinian people? It is well documented and widely accepted that groups like the Irgun and Haganah —- led by many of Israels most celebrated figures — resorted to terrorism and genocide to establish the supremacy of the Israelis.
Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by lr4444lr on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @02:32PM (#26402930)
You're aware that the Israeli military openly purged extremist groups, yes? Those paramilitary orgs predated the state of Israel to fight the British.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Altalena_Affair

Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by DSingularity on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @02:51PM (#26403236)
Really? What do you make of former Irgun leader Menachem Begin? FYI he eventually became prime minister and is definitely a celebrated figure in Israel.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Menachem_Begin

Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by Udik on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @06:16PM (#26405763)
Described by Albert Einstein and Hannah Arendt as "the leader of a party akin to the German Nazi party".

https://www.haaretz.com/jewish/.premium-1948-n-y-times-lette...

Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by shrubble on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @03:13PM (#26403530)
How many from the (Lehi)/Stern Gang and Irgun, among others, later achieved high ranking political success in Israel? Both Begin and Shamir come to mind.

Despite siding with the Nazis in WW2, Lehi membership was first granted a general amnesty and later an award was named in their honor.

Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by DSingularity on Thursday March 11, 2021 @02:41PM (#26428121)
Wow. Would never have guessed that they sided with the Nazis. Does that make them anti-Semitic?
Re:Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry by saiya-jin on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @02:03PM (#26402418)
I think Germany in 30s had broadly a very similar mindset, being humiliated, driven to utter poverty, and they felt they were doing what was necessary to survive as a nation. I guess you don't hear that as an excuse for their WWII atrocities often.

In other situation it would be funny to point direct parallels between above and state of Israel, but this ain't even slightly funny topic. They achieved impressive things, but these kind of actions make them lose any moral points pretty quickly.