Re:Iceland Pursues a User-Generated Constitution
by ignifero on Friday June 10, 2011 @06:52AM
(#2640385)
Iceland's a small country. Following wikipedia statistics, 318000*0.02 = 6360 people would be expected to contribute maximum. Excluding people of non-voting age, and considering that even less have the expertise to contribute, the number of people involved is not much higher than the size of a parliament + advisories.
Also, what about groups that will be misrepresented in the authoring process (e.g. women contribute much less in wikipedia)? I 'm very sceptical about the whole "wisdom of the crowds" politics here.
Re:Iceland Pursues a User-Generated Constitution
by borgar on Friday June 10, 2011 @09:57AM
(#2640849)
The news (especially the headlines) are somewhat is misleading on this story. The constitution if Iceland is not being "user generated". It is being written by a council of elected representatives.
The process is broadcast and updated realtime online and there there is a discussion/comments system where the council members are active. But this isn't "crowd-sourcing" in the way Wikipedia is.
Re:Iceland Pursues a User-Generated Constitution
by daedhel on Friday June 10, 2011 @09:49AM
(#2640813)
I share your skepticism. You see, I have been thinking a lot a bout democracy, decentralization and recent Iceland politics.
My conclusion is that the smaller you go, the more democratic olitics are. Period.
I share my criticism of the political globalisation, just to be laughed of afterward, but I still believe that the smaller, the most democratic, as is explified in a great way by Iceland.
Re:Iceland Pursues a User-Generated Constitution
by ignifero on Friday June 10, 2011 @11:14AM
(#2641131)
I believe it's mostly a matter of how mature and educated a society is. See counterexample also: the ban of minarets in switzerland (which practices some form of direct democracy)
I encourage anyone interested in this approach of government to watch the documentary, "us now" [1] [2].
[1] http://vodo.net/usnow
[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Us_Now
Also, what about groups that will be misrepresented in the authoring process (e.g. women contribute much less in wikipedia)? I 'm very sceptical about the whole "wisdom of the crowds" politics here.
The process is broadcast and updated realtime online and there there is a discussion/comments system where the council members are active. But this isn't "crowd-sourcing" in the way Wikipedia is.
My conclusion is that the smaller you go, the more democratic olitics are. Period.
I share my criticism of the political globalisation, just to be laughed of afterward, but I still believe that the smaller, the most democratic, as is explified in a great way by Iceland.
Edit: Found this:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_system_of_...
Of all the small countries, this leaves, well, ahem... Iceland.